Class Notes

Margaret D. Hughey, formerly of McDonald, Pennsylvania, passed away peacefully on April 20, 2024 in her home at Hawthorne Woods Assisted Living, Washington, Pennsylvania.

Born February 10, 1921, a daughter of the late Dr. John A. and Mary Robb Douglass of McDonald. She was a life-long resident of McDonald graduating from high school in 1938. She attended Muskingum College and Business Training School (now Point Park College). She and Dr. James R. Hughey of Burgettstown were married in McDonald on September 4, 1943. Upon his return from the service in 1947, they settled in McDonald where Dr. Hughey practiced medicine for thirty-five years. Dr. Jim was a veteran of World War II and the Korean Conflict. He passed away on June 22, 2000.

Margaret (Peggy) Hughey was a life-long member of First Presbyterian Church, now McDonald Presbyterian Church, where she served as an elder and served on various committees and projects. She played an active role in community service, helping to organize the Diamond Jubilee in 1964 and was also co-chairman of the Bicentennial Celebration in 1976. She was one of the founders of Lincoln Avenue Arts as well as the McDonald Trail Station and Meeting House.

She enjoyed doing crafts, knitting and painting bird pictures. Writing was also an important part of her life. She was the first editor of the McDonald High School Chronicle and a copy reader for the McDonald Outlook during the time Dr. Jim was in the military. Since that time, she has enjoyed writing about family history and other topics of interest.

She is survived by her son, James R. (Nicholette) Hughey, Jr. of McDonald; grandchildren, James R. (Joanna) Hughey, III of Carnegie and Shannon L. (Katie) Hughey of Penn Hills. Also surviving are a number of nieces and nephews.

She was preceded in death by her sisters, Betty Campbell, Rachel Hughey Malarkey and Mary Robb Ballantyne and a brother, John A. Douglass, Jr.

Betty Jane Dougherty, age 81, of Zanesville, Ohio, peacefully went to be with the Lord on April 22, 2024, at the Oaks of Bethesda in Zanesville after a long and courageous battle with Multiple System Atrophy.

Betty was born July 8, 1942, in Joliet, Illinois to the late C.A. “Doc” and Laura (Vanzant) Dougherty. She was a 1960 graduate of Zanesville High School, where she was a member of the marching band and played the flute. Following high school, Betty attended Muskingum University, where she earned a Bachelor of Arts in Economics in 1964. Following undergrad, she attended Michigan State University, where she earned her Masters of Business Administration in Accounting. She began her career as an accountant in Chicago with Arthur Anderson and then Coopers and Lybrand, before moving to Dallas, Texas, in 1973 to raise her daughter. Betty returned to live in Zanesville in 1992 and worked for her family business, Zane Casket Company, until her disease forced her to retire. In her spare time, Betty loved gardening, shopping, reading, and helping those less fortunate.

She is survived by her daughter Michelle Benoist, son-in-law Jeff, and two grandsons, Josh and Brandon of Flower Mound, Texas; her two brothers, Bill Dougherty of Zanesville, Ohio, and Robert Dougherty of Norwich, Ohio; and several nephews and nieces.

Betty was preceded in death by her mother and father, C.A, “Doc” and Laura (Vanzant) Dougherty and her two sisters-in-law, Mary Dougherty, and Mary Beth Dougherty.

Sharon Sides Wilson, 93, passed away Monday, March 18, 2024, at Wesley Glen in Columbus Ohio.  Sharon was born during the Great Depression on February 25, 1931, in Heber City, Utah to the late Albert and Pauline (Wolf) Sides.

Sharon spent her early childhood moving every couple of years because her father worked on many of the massive earth moving projects happening in the United States at the time. Some of the places she briefly called home were Utah, California, Oregon, Washington, Nevada, Idaho, South Carolina, and West Virginia.  She moved with her parents to Zanesville, Ohio in 1943.   

Sharon graduated from Zanesville (Lash) High School in 1948 where she met and then later married her high school sweetheart, Bill Wilson.  Together they began what would later become the Lumi-Lite Candle Company in the basement of their rented home on Sunkle Avenue.  They had 5 children before divorcing in 1965.  

As a single mother of 5 young children, Sharon earned her Bachelor of Arts degree (magna cum laude) in 1966 from Muskingum University (College) in New Concord, Ohio where she was also on the staff of the Alumni Association.  She earned her Master of Arts degree in 1967 from Ohio State University in Columbus, Ohio before purchasing a home and moving her family to New Concord, Ohio where she felt its small-town atmosphere would be beneficial to raising her children. 

Sharon taught hearing-impaired children in the Zanesville public school system for 25 years, three of which she was honored to have overseen a federally funded research program aimed at developing vocational education materials for the deaf. She retired from teaching in 1992. 

Over her lifetime, Sharon delighted in many different hobbies including hiking, biking, camping, photography, gardening, and a wide variety of arts and crafts.   She was proud of her heirloom roses that adorned “the wall” in front of her Main Street home and would often be found outside on a nice spring or summer day in her sunhat carefully pruning them.  She was also proud of the cross-stich square of the family home she created for the William Rainey Harper Memorial Community Quilt, presented to the village on September 17, 1994. Every time she walked past the cabin and saw the quilt on the bed, she said it gave her a thrill. 

Sharon loved to travel with her significant other, John Wynne, or with her daughter, Jan, on adventures that sometimes included her grandchildren.   Her mother, Pauline, claimed Sharon’s middle name actually should have been “traveling” because she had maintained a more or less mobile lifestyle her entire life starting from before she was born (in her mother’s womb) …to her travels in a mobile play pen in the back of the family car whenever they had to  move…to the many car and plane trips she would take as an adult to see the world. 

One of Sharon’s most memorable trips occurred in the 1960’s when she traveled to India with a group of students organized by Muskingum University (College) Professor Joe Elkins. She said the paradox of visiting a country of such astounding beauty and unfathomable poverty had a profound and lasting effect on her.  She witnessed history in the making when she found herself in London for the marriage of Lady Diana Spencer and Prince Charles and was able to take part in many of the public celebrations.   She loved telling people about sleeping on the street overnight with thousands of strangers to get a front row view of the processional to the church---her photo album from the time shows it was a worthwhile undertaking. 

Sharon was a voracious reader and always loved learning and experiencing new things.   She enjoyed taking her children on “mystery trips” for which she would awaken them in the early hours of the morning, instruct them to get dressed and into the car because they were going “somewhere” that was usually only revealed to them when they had nearly arrived.  Sharon was a member of MENSA, she loved to attend theater, music, and dance events and she also loved to entertain---her parties were legendary…and…she loved cats.  She will also be remembered for her positive outlook on life, her ability to laugh at herself, her generosity, enthusiasm, and open-mindedness, and, finally, her unflagging support of her family. 

She is survived by 4 of her 5 children, Mike Wilson of Flagstaff, Arizona, Mickey Wilson-Skarr of Bradenton, Florida, Marty Downey of Poway, California, and Jody Christensen of Terra Ceia, Florida; plus 5 grandchildren, Kelly, Sonya, Matt, Jonathan, and Alex; and 4 great grandchildren, Audrey, Lauren, William, and Jackson; and many other loving relatives and friends.

In addition to her parents, she was proceeded in death by her beloved partner of many years, John Wynne of Columbus, on December 26, 2023, and a cherished daughter, Jan Wilson, of Bradenton, Florida, on February 28, 2024. 

Sharon’s ashes are interred along with her daughter’s in the Muskingum University Columbarium. 

Patricia Ann Luster passed away on Sunday, April 7th, 2024, surrounded by loved ones at the home of her daughter, Sally Taubken, in New Stanton, Pa. Patty, as she was affectionately known, was born on August 9th, 1928 in Zanesville, Oh to Russell L. Granger and Pauline Lecrone Granger of Zanesville. Patricia was a very active wife, Mother, Grandmother, sister and friend; Patty never met a stranger and she always made everyone around her feel welcomed. She shared her time for the past 36 years between Englewood, Florida, Virginia, and Pennsylvania. Throughout her life she maintained an active lifestyle spending her time with her beloved family and friends. She participated in a variety of activities that included being a member of the Eastern Star and The Lemon Bay Woman's Club. She attended the Englewood Methodist church of Englewood, Florida and the Englewood Fellowship Church. Patty attended Muskingum College and taught school as a P.E. teacher. She thrived and lived in Englewood for 36 years where she played golf, shelled, walked the beach, went to the Jetties, did crafts, and spent lots of time with her grandchildren and great-grandchildren, who called her Yaa Yaa. She is survived by her daughters, Susan Luster, and Sally (David) Taubken, along with two grandchildren: Dan (Courtney) Taubken, Sara (Jim) Lazar; five great-grand children; Elizabeth Taubken, Gabriella Taubken, Charlotte Taubken, Michael Lazar, and Katherine Lazar. She is also survived by her sister-in-law, Myrna Granger, 4 nieces and nephews, her close friend and "adopted" daughter, Hannah Jordan Partridge and her 4 children. Patty is preceded in death by her loving husband of 48 years, Bert Luster, whom she married on November 26th, 1949, her brother, Paul David Granger, her parents, and her in-laws. 

Beverly Kay (Askew) Fenning, aged 82, passed into the loving arms of God on Saturday, March 23, 2024. Beverly was born in Morgantown, West Virginia, to Joshua Herman Askew and Melba (Menear) (Lewis) Askew on October 10, 1941. Her early education was in rural schools in western Pennsylvania, and her advanced education was at Muskingum University in New Concord, Ohio. Beverly briefly taught elementary school in Lindhurst, Ohio, then married her rolling dancing partner, Robert Fenning, on June 2, 1974. For many years Beverly was a homemaker and gardener, and served in her local church in many capacities, including singing tenor in the church choir. In Robert's retirement, Beverly and Robert were very active in Habitat for Humanity, working with local Ohio Habitat partnerships, building much needed affordable homes. Beverly also did much appreciated administrative tasks in the Habitat offices. For many years Beverly and Robert also worked on the Jimmy Carter Habitat for Humanity Annual Blitz Builds, traveling throughout the US. The also traveled from Ohio to help with a build in Orange, MA Following Robert's death in 2014, Beverly relocated to Greenfield, to live with her sister, Karin Clough. During this time Beverly became well-loved locally for her sweet smile and willing spirit. As she had for many years before, she began singing in the choir at Second Congregational Church, which brought her happiness each week. Beverly is survived by her sister Karin, by two nieces, Shauna Lynn of Greenfield, and Jenny Gabrenas and her husband Mark Gabrenas, of Athol, MA, as well as many grand and great-grandnieces and nephews, who live locally and across the US, and beloved second, third, fourth and maybe even fifth cousins, living in VA, NC and beyond.

Susan M. Cronin passed away in Naples, Florida on March 30, 2024 after a brief illness. She was surrounded by family members at her passing. Susan was a thoughtful and loving sister, spouse, mother, grandmother, and friend who will be greatly missed. She relished every opportunity to have her family around her, and she especially enjoyed being with her children and grandchildren. She is survived by her brother, Edward (Ted) Milkey; her husband, Michael D. Cronin; children, Sara Kowalczyk and her husband, Mark Kowalczyk, and Douglas Cronin and his wife, Abbey Cronin; and her four grandchildren, Brendan Kowalczyk, Julia Kowalczyk, Gus Cronin, and Will Cronin.
Susan was born in Buffalo, NY on April 6, 1948 to parents Gustave Milkey, MD and Janet Milkey. She was part of the first graduating class from Grand Island High School in Grand Island, NY before attending Muskingum College in New Concord, OH. She graduated from Syracuse University with a Master's Degree, and pursued teaching. Susan's career pivoted towards teaching writing at Syracuse University where she spent 25 years as an undergraduate writing instructor and consultant to the Maxwell School and the School of Architecture before retiring. Her love of the written word carried over to being an avid reader and belonging to book clubs in Syracuse, NY and Naples, FL.
Susan had a variety of interests including golf, reading, gardening, and playing games (especially Majong), and she was an active member of the communities she lived in. Given her keen interest in community service, Susan joined the Junior League of Syracuse in 1983 as an active and then sustainer member throughout her life. She was most proud of her work as the Parliamentarian of the League. Similarly, Susan's love of plants and flowers was evident by her long-term membership in the Four Seasons Garden Club and the countless hours she spent organizing club events and outings.
Susan also participated in the women's golf leagues at both the Onondaga Golf and Country Club in Syracuse and Eagle Creek Golf and Country Club in Florida. Susan played golf regularly with several of her friends during the summer. At Onondaga, she organized and managed the Sweeps competitions for the past several years. At both clubs, Susan enjoyed learning how to play Majong and making new friends. Whether in Syracuse or Florida, she always made time to introduce new people to the game she loved.
Despite her many activities, Susan's greatest accomplishments stemmed from her roles as a loving spouse, mother, and grandmother. Susan's greatest joy was hosting family gatherings that she would spend days preparing for, decorating the house and cooking her favorite meals and dishes to ensure that a wonderful time was had by all.

A month after the 1929 Wall Street Crash, Elizabeth (Betty) Carolyn Bryson Martel was born November 17 in Xenia, Ohio. Despite early hearing problems, she graduated with high marks from Xenia Central High School and went on to attend Muskingum College, New Concord OH.

Her family moved to Dayton, and began attending Grace United Methodist because her mother "liked how they sounded on the radio." At Grace, Betty met a young Air Force engineer from Arkansas and soon married Charles "Chuck" Martel. She worked at Wright-Patterson AFB, even witnessing an atomic bomb test in Nevada. After raising three children she returned to Wright-Patterson to earn a 20-year retirement and the Outstanding Civilian Career Service Award.

Betty served her community and touched many lives. She was a "professional volunteer"-serving as a reading tutor in the Beavercreek and Dayton Public Schools, a leader and neighborhood chair of the Girl Scouts, President of United Methodist Women at Grace United Methodist, and a member of the Cox Arboretum Wildflower Group. As an alumnus of the one-room Collins School north of Xenia, she shared its history with visiting students. In 1976, she and Charles led their church's efforts to adopt the Vietnamese refugee family of Long & Hoa Pham, so much so that they became "grandma" and "grandpa." Mutual love and respect for each other has continued throughout the years.

In addition to her volunteer work, Betty was an avid reader and enjoyed traveling, gardening, family genealogy, cooking, and playing the piano, often accompanied by Charles singing or on the tuba. A lifelong learner, she took additional college courses at Wright State University, and despite growing arthritis she continued piano lessons at Sinclair Community College into her 80s.

At the age of 94, Betty Martel died in the Memory Unit of Bethany Village, Centerville, Ohio, on April 10, 2024. She was predeceased by her parents, Harold W. Bryson and Florence Collins Bryson, brother Robert M. Bryson (Ruth), brother H. Edwin Bryson (Janet), sister Helen Brantley (Virgil) and sister Mary Anne Neff (Leo). Betty was very close to sisters Helen and Mary Anne, and was fortunate to have loving and attentive nieces living nearby, Mrs. Janine (Brian) Montgomery and Mrs. Betsy Crandall.

Betty is survived by her loving husband of 68 years, Charles R Martel, son C. Mark Martel (Kate), Capt. Cook, Hawaii; daughter Laura Carlson (John), Oakland CA; Celia K. Martel, San Antonio TX; grandchildren Andrew Carlson (Noelle), Encinitas, CA and Kylie Carlson, San Francisco CA; sister-in-law Louise Huddleston, Mitchellville, MD and brother-in-law Leo Neff, Dayton.

Mary Jo Buck died peacefully at home in Bedminster, NJ on April 9, 2024. She was born on May 14, 1923. The daughter of Harold and Arleen Haines, she was raised in LeRoy Ohio (now known as Westfield Center). She grew up during the Great Depression, learning an ethic of frugality that she carried throughout her life.
She graduated from Muskingum College, New Concord OH, with a B.S. in Chemistry. At Muskingum, she met her future husband, Thomas Marion Buck. They were married on Nov. 18, 1944, while Tom was serving in the Navy during WWII. After the war, they lived in Pittsburgh, PA for five years before relocating to Plainfield, NJ. They later moved to Basking Ridge, NJ and finally to Bedminster, NJ.
Jo was a long-time active member, deacon and elder of the Crescent Avenue Presbyterian Church in Plainfield. She was a consistent contributor to a variety of charities and travelled widely in Europe and Asia with her husband. She was an avid reader, an excellent cook, and was attentive to progressive health advice before this became popular. She had a lifelong love of music and practiced the flute every day for years, often playing duets with Tom, who played the clarinet.
Jo created a beautiful, warm and artistic home. She raised 5 children, was a wonderful mother and skilled manager of family finances. For twenty years, she worked for Hartford Steam Boiler, servicing prominent accounts in Marketing Support. After retiring from HSB, she worked for ten years as manager of Grace's Kitchen, a soup kitchen sponsored by Grace Episcopal Church in Plainfield, NJ. She was welcoming and friendly to a wide variety of customers and coordinated volunteers during cooking days when the kitchen was open to the public. Jo retired one month before her 90th birthday. She spent much of the next decade reading, walking, serving at Valerie's Soup Kitchen at Crescent Avenue Church, writing letters, and watching dogs take their owners for a walk.
Jo was predeceased by her daughter, Charlotte Elizabeth, in 1978, by her husband, Thomas Marion, in 2000, and by her son-in-law, Nick Amster, in 2020. She is survived by children David, Lucinda, Sarah, and Marian; sons-in-law Raj and Tom; grandchildren Bethany, Annika, Rosalie, Claire and Eli; great-grandchildren Atticus and Josephine. Jo donated her body to the Robert Wood Johnson Medical School Anatomical Association.

Susan M. Cronin passed away in Naples, Florida on March 30, 2024 after a brief illness. She was surrounded by family members at her passing. Susan was a thoughtful and loving sister, spouse, mother, grandmother, and friend who will be greatly missed. She relished every opportunity to have her family around her, and she especially enjoyed being with her children and grandchildren. She is survived by her brother, Edward (Ted) Milkey; her husband, Michael D. Cronin; children, Sara Kowalczyk and her husband, Mark Kowalczyk, and Douglas Cronin and his wife, Abbey Cronin; and her four grandchildren, Brendan Kowalczyk, Julia Kowalczyk, Gus Cronin, and Will Cronin.
Susan was born in Buffalo, NY on April 6, 1948 to parents Gustave Milkey, MD and Janet Milkey. She was part of the first graduating class from Grand Island High School in Grand Island, NY before attending Muskingum College in New Concord, OH. She graduated from Syracuse University with a Master's Degree, and pursued teaching. Susan's career pivoted towards teaching writing at Syracuse University where she spent 25 years as an undergraduate writing instructor and consultant to the Maxwell School and the School of Architecture before retiring. Her love of the written word carried over to being an avid reader and belonging to book clubs in Syracuse, NY and Naples, FL.
Susan had a variety of interests including golf, reading, gardening, and playing games (especially Majong), and she was an active member of the communities she lived in. Given her keen interest in community service, Susan joined the Junior League of Syracuse in 1983 as an active and then sustainer member throughout her life. She was most proud of her work as the Parliamentarian of the League. Similarly, Susan's love of plants and flowers was evident by her long-term membership in the Four Seasons Garden Club and the countless hours she spent organizing club events and outings.
Susan also participated in the women's golf leagues at both the Onondaga Golf and Country Club in Syracuse and Eagle Creek Golf and Country Club in Florida. Susan played golf regularly with several of her friends during the summer. At Onondaga, she organized and managed the Sweeps competitions for the past several years. At both clubs, Susan enjoyed learning how to play Majong and making new friends. Whether in Syracuse or Florida, she always made time to introduce new people to the game she loved.
Despite her many activities, Susan's greatest accomplishments stemmed from her roles as a loving spouse, mother, and grandmother. Susan's greatest joy was hosting family gatherings that she would spend days preparing for, decorating the house and cooking her favorite meals and dishes to ensure that a wonderful time was had by all.

Merle Edgar Heasley, age 86 of Englewood, passed away on Monday, April 1, 2024. He was a veteran of the U.S. Army and a graduate of Muskingum College. Merle had worked at Gulf Oil and later retired from Century Toro with over 35 years of service. After retirement, he worked for several years in the produce department at Kroger.He is survived by his daughters and sons-in-law: Angie (David) Wright, Cherie (Charlie) Goubeaux, grandchildren: Nathan, Emma and Brady Wright, Morgan (Brandon) Wirrig, Brett (Ashley), Madison and Jake Goubeaux, great grandson: Peyton, sister: Donna Downing, numerous nieces, nephews, relatives, and friends. He was preceded in death by his wife: Judith Jean (Schaffer) Heasley, parents: Charles and Margaret (Jordan) Heasley and 15 brother and sisters.

Hazel Louise (Ault) Blanchard, 85 of Greenville, Ohio, passed away on Monday April 1, 2024. Hazel was born October 29, 1938, in Bellaire, Ohio, the daughter of the late Henry Hewetson Jr. and Mary Ida (Long) Ault, and she was named after a beloved aunt, Hazel Knox. Hazel worked as a guidance counselor in Cochranton, PA, Southwestern City Schools near Columbus, OH, and Piqua High School, OH. Later at East Elementary School in Greenville, she began the library and media center as a librarian and helped in the school's office during the lunch hours for more than 20 years. Hazel loved to read aloud to the students who attended East School. Hazel was a graduate of Muskingum College and then received her master's degree from Ohio University. She was a founding member of the F.I.S.H. organization and volunteered and housed the food pantry for numerous years. She was a member of the Presbyterian Church where she sang in the chancel church choir. The family is very musically inclined, and Hazel played the piano and encouraged her daughters to play too. She and her husband, Leo or "Buzz" loved spending time with family and attended most of their daughters' and grandchildren's music and sports activities. Hazel is preceded in death by her parents. Hazel is survived by her husband Leo Thomas "Buzz" Blanchard of Greenville whom she married August 20, 1966 at the St. Teresa Catholic Church in Covington, Ohio; she is also survived by her children and spouse, Mary Louise Neels, and Lori Ann Johnson (Tim); her grandchildren, Theodore Neels Jr. "T.J.", Katherine Neels, Trevor Johnson, Kara Johnson (Eli) Couchman, Riley Johnson, and Kylie Johnson; her great grandchildren, Milo and Willow Couchman; and her brother and sister-in-law, Henry Hewetson and Linda (Eaton) Ault. 

Jack Crowther, 74, passed away in Gainesville, GA on March 8, 2024, after a brief illness. 

Jack received a Bachelor of Science Degree from Muskingum with majors in math and physics. During his Muskie years he was a member of the men's basketball team and the Ulster Club.

Following graduation, Jack returned to his hometown of Elyria, Ohio and lived there until 2015, when he moved to Georgia. He was a businessman and enjoyed playing and watching sports, especially basketball and baseball. He was immensely proud of his children and grandchildren.

Jack is survived by sons Nicholas (Ben Esthus) and Zachary (Megan Hunter); daughter Casey (Timothy) Clauss; grandsons Calvin, Owen, Miles and Colson; wife 1971- 2015 Laurine (Namy) Muskingum Class of 1971.
 

The Rev. Dr. David P. Birch, 98, of Lititz, PA died Thursday, March 21, 2024 at Moravian Manor. Born in Youngstown, Ohio, he was the son of the late Roy E. Birch, Sr. and Emma Morris Birch. David was the husband of Janet Baugh Birch. They celebrated their 70th anniversary on September 3, 2023. He has lived in S. Central Pennsylvania for 48 years. He graduated from high school in Struthers, OH in 1944. He then joined the US Navy from 1944 to 1946 where he served in the Medical Corps. He graduated from Muskingum College in New Concord, OH in He graduated from Pittsburgh Theological Seminary in 1952 with a Master of Religion degree. In 1977 he earned the Doctor of Ministry degree from Pittsburgh Seminary. David served as Minister of Education at the Sunset Hills Presbyterian Church in Pittsburgh, PA, Pastor of the House of Hope Presbyterian Church in Bellerose, NY, Head of Staff of the First Presbyterian Church, Dodge City, KS, Head of Staff of the First Presbyterian Church, Wheeling, WV and as Mission Consultant on the staff of the synod of the Trinity of the Presbyterian Church USA. He retired in 1986. After retirement he served as Interim Pastor of the Derry Presbyterian Church in Hershey, PA and as Visitation Pastor for the Paxton Presbyterian Church in Harrisburg, PA. Dr Birch was interested in the needs of people throughout his ministry. While in Kansas he was instrumental in bringing mental health services to Ford County, KS. He was chairperson for Red Cross Disaster Relief for Ford County. In Wheeling he was the Chairperson of the city Human Rights Commission for four years. He was one of the prime movers in an effort for the churches of Wheeling to work together in a Cooperative ministry to the poor. At the death of Martin Luther King he, along with several other Wheeling Pastors, formed the Greater Wheeling Community Development Council to work for better relations among the races. He served as the Chairperson of the Volunteer Advisory Board at Hershey Medical Center. He served as Vice Chairperson of the Board of Trustees of Davis and Elkins College in Elkins, WV. He was very active in the community life at Moravian Manor where he lived for the past 24 years. He served as President of the Residents Association, the Board of Trustees and numerous other committees. While serving in New York he served as the Clerk of the United Presbyterian Synod of New York. In Kansas he was the Moderator of the Presbytery of the High Plains and in Wheeling he was the Moderator of the Upper Ohio Valley Presbytery. He also served as a member of a number of Presbytery Committees, usually in the area of mission development of youth work. He was popular with young people and directed many summer camps and conferences. Dr. Birch enjoyed traveling, searching for antiques, refinishing furniture, photography, writing, singing and reading. He enjoyed teaching and writing study papers. He is survived by his wife, Janet; daughter, Deborah of Greenfield Park, NY; son, Timothy and grandson Jason of Wheeling WV.

Britta Louise Nesbitt Blair was born on August 13, 1938, the daughter of Harold Emerson Nesbitt and Britta Louise Postelwaite Nesbitt. She attended Indiana High School where she graduated with honors and was the winner of the Lubold Award, an outstanding citizenship award presented by Superintendent Jesse Lubold. She matriculated at Muskingum University, but transferred in her junior year to Mount Holyoke University, where she was a 1960 graduate with a degree in chemistry. Following graduation, Britta married McClellan Gordon Blair and moved to Rochester, NY, where she obtained employment as editor of Eastman Kodak's technical bulletins while her husband pursued a doctoral degree in Physics at the University of Rochester. It was here that their first three children were born: Elizabeth Hall Blair Wallwork (1961), Christina Reinhardt Blair Lubold (1963), and Janet Nesbitt Blair West (1965). A son, James Gordon Blair (1970) was born after the couple's return to Indiana. Britta was, first and foremost, a dedicated mother and an active supporter of her children in all of their activities. She was an avid and successful gardener, taking pride in her horticultural specimens, and was a long-time member of the Indiana Garden Club, serving in many leadership roles within the organization. She developed outstanding skills in flower arrangement and was a regular winner in local and regional flower shows. She passed her expertise to others by becoming a nationally accredited flower show judge. She was also a talented and expert knitter and seamstress. Active in Calvary Presbyterian Church affairs, Britta served as deacon for many years. She also participated in Questers and the IUP Museum Board of Directors. Britta is survived by her children and their spouses and 11 grandchildren: Britta Wallwork Pate and husband Jason, Alexander, and James Wallwork, Anthony, Elizabeth, and Michael Lubold, David West and wife Jenny, Eric West and wife Aja, and Matthew, Isabella and Emma Blair. Also surviving are six great-grandchildren, Emmylou, Weston, Zella, Waylan and Elinor Pate and Henry West. She was preceded in death by her husband, McClellan, her brother, James Harold Nesbitt and her sister, Clara Elizabeth (Libby) Griffiths. 

Richard Bradley “Brad" Jeffers of Wilmington died on April 2 surrounded by God’s angels. Brad was born September 14, 1929. A proud native Delawarean, son of the late Rev. H Clifford Jeffers and Mary White Jeffers. A graduate of Wilmington ‘High School’ in 1947, he was known for his outstanding athletic abilities; particularly in track, holding records and winning 1st at the State Championship in 100-yard low hurdles. At Wilmington High, Brad lettered in 3 sports. Upon graduation he enlisted and served in Washington, D.C. as a member of the Military Police. He began college at Muskingum College in New Concord, Ohio but was re-called to serve in the Far East Command during his college tenure. Upon return from Korea, he re-entered Muskingum where he enjoyed academics, sports, and the camaraderie of the Stag Fraternity. He also ran as part of the 4-member 880-yard Championship team at Muskingum in 1953.

He married Mary Elaine Honeychurch on December 29, 1951 at Silverbrook United Methodist Church in Wilmington. She was his loving mate for their life together. They had fond stories, particularly of their days at Muskingum in ’51-53.

Finishing college, he went on to teach and coach in Ohio and Delaware; always a mentor to young people. He helped shape future generations at Urbana Local, West Liberty High (Urbana, Ohio), Harrington High (Harrington, DE), DeLaWarr, Dickinson, Brandywine Springs Junior High and McKean High School (Wilmington, Delaware).

While teaching, he pursued his Masters Degree at West Chester University and completed graduate work at the University of Delaware. With his talent for leadership, he entered the ranks of school administration; as an assistant principal at both Dickinson and McKean. He also was honored to be the acting principal at Brandywine Springs prior to its sale to the Hercules company in the late 70’s. He had the honor of being inducted into Wilmington High’s and McKean’s Walls of Fame. Additionally, he was recognized at McKean’s 50th Anniversary. He believed in the importance of involvement in one’s profession and was a member of the Delaware School Administrators’ Association and also more recently the Delaware Retired School Personnel Association.

Not to be one to sit on the sidelines; he could be found managing North Star pool in the summer, coaching little league and semi-pro teams (Artway) in the spring and officiating football in the fall. He was a member of the American Red Cross for 35 years.

Church was an important part of his life, and he was an active member at Red Clay Creek Presbyterian Church as well as Silverbrook United Methodist Church.

After retirement, Brad made a summer home in Ocean View for a period of time with family around him on every block. With his commitment to young people, he decided that he could also drive a school bus for the Red Clay Consolidated School District and Sutton Bus company during the school year. He also was a lead in for funerals at Gracelawn Cemetery for many years.

In 2004, Mary and Brad decided to be snowbirds, and called Estero, Florida home, where Brad started and arranged for the construction of horseshoe pits and organized the horseshoe league which generated much enthusiasm among his neighbors of Cypress Bend.

Most recently, Brad called Forwood Manor and Harbor Chase home. The family is most appreciative of the support of the Harbor Chase and Compassionate Care staff.

Brad was preceded in death by his wife, Mary. He is survived by his children; Mary Norris (Ed), Jim Jeffers (Patti) his sister, Janie (Phil), and his sister-in-law (Charolette). He was the proud PopPop Brad to 2 grandsons; Bucky (Caitlin) and Randy, and 4 great-grandchildren.

Benjamin Orman Shaver, born on November 8, 1924 in Moxahala, Perry County, Ohio, peacefully passed away at the age of 99 on March 27,2024 in Waterville, Ohio. He was a dedicated educator deeply involved in the education of young people throughout his life.

Benjamin, known as Ben, served in the Army from 1943 to 1946, stationed at the 98th Station Hospital in Chakulia, India, and the 2nd Convalescent Hospital in Calcutta, India.

After his military service, Ben got a Bachelor of Arts degree in 1950 from Muskingum College and a Master of Education degree from Ohio University in 1954.

He pursued a career in education, serving as a teacher and basketball coach in Adamsville and Republic, Ohio. He later became the Superintendent of Millcreek-West Unity School District, was the first Superintendent of Hillsdale Local Schools, and Ashland County Schools. Ben also worked as a Member Service Representative at Firelands Electric.

Throughout his career, Ben received many awards and honors. He was humbled by each recognition. A few of these awards are:
Muskingum County Coach of the Year-1953
Seneca County Coach of the the Year-1954
President of Ohio Association of Local School Superintendents-1967
President of Ohio County Superintendents Association-1978
Muskingum University Distinguished Service Award-2017

Outside of his professional life, Ben enjoyed traveling with his late wife, Alyce, whom he met at Muskingum College. They were a remarkable team who supported each others careers. Their great past time was exploring every continent except Australia and traveling all oceans, including the Antarctic Ocean. They were members of Jeromesville United Methodist Church and Ashland Presbyterian Church.

Benjamin Shaver is survived by his daughters, Barbara Shaver Christensen(Phil) and Karen Shaver Swinehart(Bob). He has four grandchildren Ben Swinehart(Tally), Allyson Lee (Derek), Sarah Lewis(Josh),and Jennifer Christensen(Swapnil Chaudhari). He has 7 great grandchildren. He was preceded in death by his wife, Alyce Marie Cowan Shaver, his parents Samual Benjamin Shaver and Muriel Amerine, two brothers, Maurice Jay and Philip Ross, and a sister, Leona Hildred Webb.

David Crawford McCoy, age 95, passed away on March 31, 2024.  He was born to the late John C. McCoy and Ella Mae Crawford in Franklin, Pennsylvania on January 11, 1929.  David was preceded in death by his brothers, James Reed, Kenneth Edward, and Lyle Stanley.

After graduation from Emlenton High School, Emlenton, Pennsylvania, he attended Muskingum College, New Concord, Ohio.  He graduated in 1952 with a Bachelor’s Degree in Science with Music Supervision. David was a member of the Alban Club and a life member of Phi Mu Alpha Sinfonia National Music Fraternity.

At Muskingum College, he met Polly (Mary Pauline Coleman), his lifelong soul mate.  They were married in McKeesport, Pennsylvania on December 27, 1952.

He served in United States Air Force Bands as a bandsman at Selfridge AFB, Michigan. Studied bassoon with Hugh Cooper (Detroit Symphony and University of Michigan).  Transferred to McChord AFB, Tacoma, Washington. Along with the McChord AFB Band, he played in the College of Puget Sound and the Tacoma Civic Orchestra – Principal Bassoon.  Polly and David had their first child – Kristen (Paul Koning), in 1956, at the base hospital.

Upon discharge in 1956, Polly, Kris and David returned to Ann Arbor, Michigan where he earned a Master’s Degree in Music – Woodwind Performance. He majored in bassoon with Hugh Cooper and played in the U of M Symphony Band – Principal Bassoon – Dr. William D. Revelli, Director of Bands and clarinet in the Marching Band – George Cavender – Asst. Director of Bands.

Teaching career in Michigan:  1958 – 1963 he taught at Blissfield High School. In 1958, the second child Beth (Richard Cooler) was born in Adrian, Michigan. Third child Todd (Alice) was born in 1960 in Adrian. 1963 – 1971 David taught at Jackson High School. David was named Michigan Teacher of the Year – Orchestra in 1970. Fourth child Amy was born in Jackson, Michigan in 1966.  David taught at Olivet College from 1971 – 1978. Fifth child Scott (Kim) was born in Charlotte, Michigan in 1971. From 1979 – 1990 David taught at East Grand Rapids High School, where he retired from teaching.  He was Music Director and Conductor of The Grand Rapids Youth Orchestra for nine years. David judicated Orchestra and Band Festivals and Solo and Ensemble Festivals for 40 years. He was co-founder with Joseph Nelson and arranger of the Westwinds  - (Woodwind Quintet + Piano) for 15 years.

David leaves behind his wife, 5 children, 10 grandchildren and 6 great grandchildren.

Proud parents of their five children, David and Polly were keenly interested in their families’ journey through life.

Inurnment services with military honors for Arthur Edwin Brownell, 97, of Heath, will be held at Workman Cemetery, Danville, followed by a Celebration of Life at a later date this spring. Art, a United States Army WWII Veteran, died at his home surrounded by the love of his family, on Saturday, March 16, 2024. He was born in Walton, New York on October 27, 1926, to the late Richard Claude and Evelyn (Arthur) Brownell. A graduate of Delhi High School, New York, Art received his BA in Education from Muskingum College, followed by his Masters Degree from SUNY Oneonta. He continued his studies and had almost completed his Doctorate in Administration. He taught Jr. High and High School for many years in Fairport, New York prior to moving back to Central Ohio. At an early age Art fell in love with baseball and carried this passion with him for all of his days. He had fond memories of playing ball in high school, college, semi-professionally, and even during his time in the US Army. He dedicated many years as a coach and umpire, and continued play within multiple softball leagues over the years. He was an avid fan of the New York Yankees and looked forward to opening day every season. He had a creative mind and was a talented artist, drawing with pencil and pastels. Art never gave up his love of learning and enjoyed reading, especially when the topic was of sports or history. Art felt each day to be important and every task to be vital, and wanted to be remembered for such. He will be greatly missed by his daughter, Jennie (Wayne) Hall; daughter-in-law, Mary Matthews-Brownell; grandchildren, Kerensa Ann Ecker, Matthew Brownell (Jennifer Anderson), Emme Brownell, Katie Brownell, Steve (Sara) Hall, and Brady (Elizabeth) Hall; great-grandchildren, Hanna, Ethan, Morgan, Tiffany, Benjamin, and Elijah; and many nieces and nephews. In addition to his parents, Art was preceded in death by his wife, Shirley (Workman) Brownell; his son, Jeffrey Michael Brownell; and siblings, Richard (Anne) Brownell, Robert (Mary) Brownell, Alice Martin, and Mary Brownell.

Carolyn died March 18 at her longtime Tulsa home. She was born April 26, 1937 in Oshkosh, Wisconsin, where her family had deep roots in both local and state history and politics. She attended Shattuck-St. Mary's Preparatory School in Faribault, MN and then Muskingum University in New Concord, OH. In 1959 she married Stephen Bell, also of Oshkosh, and in 1973 the couple, together with their two young children Catherine and Jeffrey, moved to Tulsa, where Stephen became a professor at OSU. In addition to being a loving homemaker, Carolyn served 26 years as a burn technician at the Hillcrest Medical Center, often working the challenging night shift so that she could be home for her family during the day. Carolyn's exceptionally-beautiful singing voice brought much joy to the Tulsa community. She was a well-known member vocalist at John Knox Presbyterian Church, performing as well at Temple Israel, the Hyechka Women's Chorus and numerous other area events and ceremonies during the more than five decades she lived in Tulsa. Her talent, professionalism and caring spirit will be deeply missed. As a young woman, Carolyn was recognized as an accomplished horsewoman. She was also an avid reader, needle crafter and amateur artist and poet. She and her husband loved to celebrate their Scottish heritage by participating in the Ceilidh, a local Scottish dance group. Carolyn is preceded in death by her parents Philetus and Elizabeth Sawyer, her husband, Stephen and her two sisters, Betty Sawyer Taylor and Mary Sawyer Orth. In addition to her two children, Catherine Bell Bales (Robert) and Jeffrey Bell, she is survived by her grandchildren Alicia Lee (Evan), Kyle Bales, Stephanie McKeever (Shane) and great-grandchildren Andrew, Grace and Sophia Kingsley, Stella-Rose McKeever and Kiera Lee, as well as many nieces and nephews.

David A. Ludwig, a long time resident of Glen Ellyn, IL passed from this life into heaven on Sunday February 25, 2024. He was a loving husband, father, grampy and great-grampy.

Born in Barberton, Ohio February 21, 1936 to parents Walter John Ludwig and Betty Kline Ludwig. David graduated from Muskingum College in 1959 with a BS in Mathematics. He then enlisted in the US Army and was stationed in Germany where he toured Europe playing basketball on the Army team known as The Big Blue. On his return from the Army he took a job with Western Electric Company in Columbus, OH where he was a member of the engineering computer group and trained on the new computers that were becoming the forefront of the manufacturing and engineering world. Western Electric moved David to Princeton, New Jersey in 1971 where he was an instructor. In 1973 David moved to the office in Lisle, IL where he worked in software design and project management. He received his Masters Degree from Purdue University in Computer Science in 1975. In the late 70's David joined five other gentlemen at the small independent company of Digital Systems House / UNIQ where he continued to develop software and consult with businesses to help them implement and manage their computer systems.

He is survived by his loving wife of 60 year Phyllis, son Jeff (Laura) of Orcas Island, WA, son Mike of Lombard, IL and daughter Amy (Reece) Chambers of Ringgold, GA. Grandchildren are Jessica (Brendan) Fahey, Sarrah Ludwig, Molly Ludwig, Emily Ludwig and Cole Ludwig. Great-Grandchildren are Delilah and Alyce Fahey. He is also survived by his sisters-in-law Anne Nedolast and Ruth Ludwig as well as nieces and nephews.

David was an active member of the First Presbyterian Church of Glen Ellyn, IL. He served on numerous committees as well as the Board of Deacons. David's passion for helping people led to his volunteer leadership with Bridge Communities and Sharing Connections where he served on the Board of Directors, mentored, helped and housed people in need.

Throughout David's life he loved the outdoors. David learned to be patient, quiet, observant and have a personal relationship with nature. David was happiest when he was planning a fishing trip, on a fishing trip or talking about his most recent fishing trip.

Suzanne Barnes Brown, 83, of Medina, Ohio, passed away surrounded by her loving family Saturday, March 16, 2024.

She was born July 6, 1940, in Buffalo, New York to Paul and Susan Seidel as the youngest, with three other siblings, Marian, Paul, and Dick.

In her early childhood, the family moved to several towns along the Erie Railroad, but she spent the majority of her childhood in Meadville, Pennsylvania. She attended Muskingum University and Case Western Reserve University, where she graduated with degrees in nursing. After college, she married her husband of 38 years, Phillip Barnes, and settled in Medina, Ohio where they raised their four children.

In addition to her nursing career, Sue dedicated her life to service. She spent years volunteering for various organizations and most recently, dedicated her and her beloved dog, Casey’s, time at Western Reserve Hospice of Medina. In 2005, she remarried Walley Brown who preceded her in death in 2007. Sue will be remembered by family and friends by her steadfast faith in God and unrelenting kindness; a woman of integrity, courage, and a youthful spirit.

Sue is survived by her children, Bonnie (Bill) Meadows, Becky (Craig) Summers, Jenny Doraty, and Jeff (Shannon) Barnes. She is also survived by fifteen grandchildren, Jordan Bruzda, Adam (Maria) Harris, Jessica (Trent) Johnson, Sam (Marissa) Meadows, Meghan (Marc) Ineman, Andrew Harris (Karlie), Alex Harris, Katherine (Jake) Kinsey, Jack (Rachel) Meadows, Mitch Doraty (Izzi), Molly Meadows (Wes), Marie Meadows, Norah (Mike) Bacho, Sophia Barnes, and Ben Barnes; as well as eleven great-grandchildren.

She was preceded by three special family friends, Kenneth Houck and John and Marie Reali.

Rose Ann Swope Machina, 89, of Indianapolis, passed away March 11, 2024. She was born November 17, 1934 in Zanesville, Ohio to the late Russell and Martha Swope. Rose graduated Magna Cum Laude from Muskingum University in 1956. She married Rev. Francis Machina, August 4, 1962, and he preceded her in death January 8, 2012. Rose was a bookkeeper for Lutheran Child & Family Services for over 20 years. She was a past member of Christ Lutheran Church, Irvington, and a current member of St. John Lutheran Church. As a partner in Frank's ministry for almost 50 years, she was active in church choir, Ladies Aid, LWML, Lutheran World Relief, teaching Sunday School, VBS, member visitations, and bible studies. As her health declined, and travel was difficult, she particularly loved studying God's word with her friends at Fall Creek Church. A Memorial Service will be held Saturday, March 23, 2024 at 11:00 a.m. at St. John Lutheran Church, 6630 Southeastern Avenue, with visitation one hour prior. Rose is survived by her children, Laurie R. Gwaltney (David) and Tim L. Machina (Tina); and grandchildren, Rose Alyse Cannon (Bradan) and Holton C. Gwaltney. She was preceded in death by an infant son, Christopher Machina.

homas A. Wilson, III, 84, of Washington, died Tuesday, January 24, 2023, in UPMC Presbyterian Hospital, Pittsburgh.

He was born July 7, 1938, in North Braddock, the son of the late Thomas A. Wilson, Jr. and Florence M. Phillips Wilson.

Mr. Wilson was a graduate of Turtle Creek High School, and then graduated from Muskingum College with a B.S. in education with a major in mathematics.

He taught mathematics in the Trinity Area School District for 34 years, retiring in 1996.

In his spare time he enjoyed making stained glass and fused glass artwork, and visiting his cottage at Youghiogheny Lake.

He was a member of Bethel Presbyterian Church in Prosperity, where he previously served as an elder.

He served his country as a Sergeant in the United States Army Reserves from 1960 to 1966.

He was blessed to receive a heart transplant in 1997 and a kidney transplant in 2000, and was a strong advocate for organ donation. He spent some time volunteering and speaking at events for organ donation through C.O.R.E. (the Center for Organ Recovery and Education).

On August 25, 1962, he married Rebecca E. Jones, and had two daughters. Mrs. Wilson died March 27, 1991.

On June 6, 1992, he married Judith I. Cooper, who survives.

Also surviving are: daughters, Rebecca Ann Schreiber and Lisa Lynn Cino; and four grandchildren, Rebecca, Julianna, Kara and Joseph Cino.

Harry (Sam) Custer, a devoted Christian and beloved family man, passed away peacefully on February 27, 2024, at the age of 92. Sam was born on September 20, 1931, in Canton, Ohio, and grew up in the small town of Conotton, Ohio. He graduated with a degree in chemistry from Muskingum University and then served two years in an artillery division of the United States Army. He then went on to work for Goodyear, employed as a chemist in the manufacturing of air springs. During his 35-year career, Sam received several patent awards for his work. Beyond his career, Sam was known for his infectious wit and friendly nature. He had a unique ability to connect with people from all walks of life and always had a joke or story at the ready. Sam's kindness and sense of humor endeared him to everyone he met. In his free time, Sam enjoyed fishing and treasured the moments spent with his family. He loved to be outdoors, chopping wood for his fireplace, and taking long walks in the field. He had a special love for animals, especially his black labs, Gracie and Annie. Sam was a long-time member of Bremen Bethel Presbyterian Church where he spent many years singing in the choir. Sam lived a life defined by his unwavering faith and commitment to his family. He is survived by his children, John (Anita) Custer, Mary (Ray) Schmidt, Tod (Donna) Custer, Alice (David) DuBois and Sam Custer, 23 grandchildren and 15 great-grandchildren. He was preceded in death by his wife of 49 years, Martha. 

Elizabeth Brooks Harrington O'Donnell, age 92, of Acworth, Georgia, passed away on Wednesday, February 21, 2024, just days shy of her 93rd birthday. Elizabeth had previously resided in Buffalo, New York, Oswego, New York, North Fort Myers, Florida and also Blairsville, Georgia. Elizabeth was born in Buffalo, New York to the late Emilie and the late Henry Harrington. She graduated from Hamburg High School (Class of 1948) where she met her husband, Lewis O'Donnell during her senior year. She had attended Muskingum College and proudly kept her yearbooks from her time there. Elizabeth and Lewis were married on September 6, 1952 at Wayside United Presbyterian Church in Wanakah, New York. She endearingly kept a photo plate hanging in her apartment to commemorate the special day. Elizabeth's sister, Patricia Brainard, and Lew's brother, Robert O'Donnell, bore witness to the couple's marriage as Elizabeth wore her sister in law Ginny's gown. While raising her three children, Elizabeth received a Bachelor of Science Degree followed by a Master of Science in Education Degree from SUNY College at Oswego. She worked as an elementary school teacher, a reading specialist and a school librarian/media specialist until retiring to Florida. Elizabeth had a variety of hobbies that changed over time including walking, swimming and boating; dancing and dressing up to go out; drawing and painting; volunteering in her local thrift store; playing bridge and other games; traveling and taking trips to Australia, New Zealand, Fiji, Europe including Eastern Europe to the Black Sea, China, Russia, Finland, Ireland and throughout the US including Alaska; and watching sports especially Syracuse Orange University Basketball and the Atlanta Braves. Elizabeth Brooks Harrington O'Donnell is preceded by her husband of 55 years, Lewis "Lew" B. O'Donnell, who passed away in August of 2007; son, Michael O'Donnell; and grandson, Travis O'Donnell. Her memory will be cherished by her children, Kathryn Hoefer and Daniel O'Donnell; daughter -in-law, Sue Rumer O'Donnell; grandchildren, Bryan Hoefer, Mark Hoefer, Erin O'Donnell and Colin O'Donnell; great-grandchildren, Audrey Hoefer, Blake Hoefer and one on the way (due in July); and siblings, Roger Harrington and Patricia Brainard.

Dr. William F. Whirl, 83, a longtime resident of Hermitage, passed away late Thursday evening, March 7, 2024, in St. Paul’s Home, Greenville.

Dr. Whirl was born on April 28, 1940, in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, a son of the late Solomon F. and Mary W. (Lepard) Whirl.

Following dental school, William served two years as a dentist in the U.S. Navy at Yorktown, Virginia. Upon his honorable discharge in 1969, he settled in Hermitage, Pennsylvania.

He retired due to health issues in January 1996, after 27 years of dental practice in Hermitage. Dr. Whirl was known for his expertise in endodontics (root canals). 

Dr. Whirl was a longtime member of the American Dental Association. He was a delegate to the Ninth District Dental Society for many years and served on the Dental Peer Review Committee in 1977/78. He served in all the chairs of the County Association and was its president in 1978/79.

Dr. Whirl was a member of First Presbyterian Church, Sharon.

He married the former Phyllis Jane Hipsley, of Sharon on December 5, 1964 and she preceded him in death September 9, 2006.

He enjoyed golf and classic cars. He was a member of the Antique Automobile Club of America and its local Shenango Valley Region branch and served on the club’s board of directors.

In addition to his parents and first wife, Dr. Whirl was preceded in death by a son, Barret Whirl.

Joseph Paul Herrmann, a beloved husband, father, grandfather, and proud veteran, passed away on February 27, 2024, at the age of 88. Born on November 27, 1935, in Crafton, PA, Paul led a remarkable life filled with love, service, and dedication.

Paul proudly served his country in the Army's 82nd Airborne Division, demonstrating courage and commitment throughout his service. After his military tenure, he pursued his education, graduating from Muskingum College in 1961, where he laid the foundation for a successful career and a fulfilling life.

In 1961, Paul married the love of his life, Margaret McKelvey. Together, they shared over 50 years of love, companionship, and unwavering support until Margaret's passing in 2011.

Paul dedicated over two decades of his professional life to Worthington Industries, where his hard work, integrity, and dedication left a lasting impact on colleagues and the community. His career took him from Ohio to Kentucky, North Carolina, Oklahoma, and back to Ohio. Paul was known for creating positive work environments, solving issues, and generating business wherever he went.

In 1992, Paul and Margaret retired to Sarasota, Florida, where they embraced a slower pace of life and enjoyed the warmth of the sunshine state. Paul was an active member of the Senior softball community in Venice and Sarasota, where his passion for the sport brought joy to many. He was an integral part of several softball travel teams, leaving behind a legacy of camaraderie and sportsmanship.
Paul's generosity knew no bounds, and his love for animals was evident in his compassionate nature. He leaves behind cherished memories and a legacy of kindness that will be remembered by all who knew him. He loved projects and helping others, and he was adored by those who knew him.

Paul is survived by his loving children, Heather Herrmann Parentice (spouse Doug Parentice) and Paul Talbott Herrmann (spouse Rachelle Rippen), as well as his adoring grandchildren, William McKelvey Parentice and Paige Miller Parentice.

Paul Herrmann will be deeply missed by his family, friends, and all those whose lives he touched. His legacy of love, kindness, and service will continue to inspire and uplift us all.

Kelly Michelle Stacy, of West Chester, passed away unexpectedly on December 29, 2023. Born to John D. and Margie (nee Mahan) Stacy on May 16, 1963, in Cincinnati, Ohio. A graduate of Muskingum College with a degree in Psychology. Kelly went on to work for Alkermes as the senior human resources manager and business partner for the last 18 years. She enjoyed going to work every day and met lifelong friends who became her family along the way. Kelly had a love of nature, gardening, and flowers. She had a green thumb when it came to planting anything. Her patience drew her to the "she shed" everyday where she tended to her plants. Animals and gardening are what made her happy. She was the aunt of all aunts. Dedicated, devoted and supportive. She spent time with her nieces and nephews every chance she could. Together at family gatherings or holidays and in individual settings, like the Super Bowl in LA with her nephew. She loved them dearly and the feeling was mutual. Kelly was a generous caring soul who loved nothing more than to be with her family. She took her parents to dinner often and even on a life changing trip for two weeks last summer. She always took time for the important people and things in her life. Preceded in death by her sweet fur babies, Molly, Chloe, Jake, Lucy and Spooky. Kelly is survived by her beloved parents, John 'Jack' and Margie Stacy, siblings, Jeffrey (Laurie) Stacy and Jennifer (David) Greensfelder, nieces and nephews, Sarah (Liam) Wallace, Morgan Stacy, Allison Greensfelder, Ryan Greensfelder and Emily Stacy and many friends who became her family.

Donna Anderson, 96, passed away surrounded by family on February 24, 2024. Born on a farm in Ohio in 1927 to Fred and Marie Sterrett, she earned a BA in Education from Muskingum College, and later an MA from Michigan State University. She married WWII war veteran George Anderson in 1949 and bucked the culture of the 1950's by working outside of the home in a profession she excelled at and loved, teaching. She taught for 24 years at East Lansing's Marble Elementary School at a time of dynamic changes in educational theory and practice. After retirement, Donna worked part-time to supervise and mentor MSU student teachers. Donna was revered by her husband and daughters for her equanimity and strength; she was an attentive listener, calm in a storm, and guided her students and her daughters to find their own answers. And she loved fun! As her 97th birthday approached this April and her health waned, she craved good news and would laugh at family jokes 50 years old. Donna embraced life to the end, modeling for her family, as always, living with grace. She lived and imparted the philosophy "things work out." Preceded in death by her husband of 60 years, Donna is survived and greatly missed by her family, which she considered her greatest legacy: daughters and sons-in-law, Jill and Thomas Schaberg and Valerie and Michael Raymond, grandchildren Anna (Brian), Maggie (Ryan), Nicholas (Jenna), and great-grandchildren, Grace, Louise, Ben, William, Andrew, Poppy, Betty, Marlowe, Noelle. 

The Rev. M. Dudley Rose, born March 09, 1941, entered into the full meaning
of our Easter Faith on Friday, October 27, 2023. Preceding him in physical
death were his parents; Bob and Kay Rose, and his sister Kathy Ondo. Pastor
Rose leaves, for the time being, his wife of 47years, Dorothy Creps Rose;
daughters, Sheri Dowden, Heather (Greg) Hammonds, and Deborah (Will)
Kopp and ten grandchildren.

A third generation Presbyterian Minister, he served congregations in
Pennsylvania, Ohio, Georgia and was founding Pastor of Geneva
Presbyterian in Switzerland Florida, where his cremated remains will be
inurned. A Certified Interim, Rev. Rose worked with churches in Louisiana,
Florida and Montana. He also was Dean of the Chapel at Grove City PA
College, Moderator of the Presbytery of Greater Atlanta and was an
experienced Conflict Management Consultant. He retired as Head of staff in
2010 from McDonough Presbyterian Church who honored him with Pastor
Emeritus status.

Pastor Rose attended the University of Cincinnati on a football scholarship,
graduated from Muskingum (OH) College and Princeton Theological
Seminary. Continuing education included St. Andrews University, Scotland,
and the American Summer Institute, Switzerland. He coached football at
Riverside High School in Western PA for eight years while also serving a
Presbyterian Church. Rev. Rose was Chaplain for Syria Shrine Temple,
Pittsburgh, PA, as well as Chaplain with the Henry County Police
Department. His book “Life Lessons from the Table” was published in 2007.

Brenda Sue Hogue, 62, of Coshocton passed away Sunday February 18, 2024, at Riverside Methodist Hospital in Columbus. Brenda was born in Bakersville on June 29, 1961, to the late Dale A. Wilson and Wanda K. (Randles) Karns. She graduated from Ridgewood High School class of 1979. Brenda also graduated Magna Cum Laude in 1993 from MATC for Medical Assisting, again from Zane State in 1999 for Physical Therapy Assisting, and later in 2005 from Muskingum University with her BA in Special Education and finally, she earned her master's degree in education from Kent State University. Brenda loved working with children with disabilities and was a thirteen-year employee at Ida Sue School of Wooster, Ohio. Brenda was active in the community as a 55-year Grange member, and dedicated member of the Coshocton Christian Tabernacle Church where she taught Sunday school and VBS, she loved all the children of the church. Brenda is survived by her children Kevin Hogue of Coshocton, Kendra Hogue of Indianapolis, IN, and Kyle Hogue of Coshocton; her beloved six-grandchildren, David, Christian, Rubianna, Brentlee, Kenlee, and Aiden; one sister Debra K. Chapman of Newcomerstown; brother Dale Wilson Jr. of New Philadelphia; step -mother Jean Wilson of Pembroke, GA; and two step siblings Kathie Steinberger and Josh Howell. 

Elizabeth Claire Nutting (Betsy) passed away February 10, 2024 at Lehigh Valley Hospital hospice after a long, hard fought battle with pancreatic cancer. Betsy was born in Wilkes-Barre, PA. She was the daughter of Robert E. Nutting, Sr and Mary Weyer Nutting and sister of the late John Nutting.
Betsy received a BA in art education from Muskingum College in Ohio and an MEd in special education at Acadia University. Betsy was a caring educator teaching art therapy at nursing homes and special education students at schools in Philadelphia as well as at Upper Perkiomen middle school and Meade elementary school in Allentown PA.
Betsy was known for her kindness and generosity to family and friends and especially for her animals. In addition to her dogs Pachay and Jackie, Betsy adopted 11 cats into her home and was a part of a feral cat support group in Allentown. Her love of all creatures led to her creating a wildlife habitat in her back garden to nourish bees, butterflies and birds.
A third order Franciscan, Betsy honored her faith by singing in the choir, teaching Sunday School, doing pastoral care, volunteering at assisted living facilities and pursuing her Bible studies. She was able to travel widely in Europe and The Holy Land where she traced the origins of her faith and formed many friendships with her fellow travelers.
Betsy is survived by her brother Robert E. Nutting, Jr (Sandra), her nephew Jeremy Nutting (Amy), her niece Carey Goldblatt (Jeremy) and six great nieces and nephews.

William Dean "Bill" Phillips, 76, of Newark, died Sunday, April 28, 2019 at the Selma Markowitz Hospice Center. He was born February 23, 1943 in Dennison, OH to the late Carl Phillips and Edith Bates.

Bill was a member of Christ United Methodist Church. He was a teacher for 32 years and also coached baseball, basketball, and football. He was a volunteer at the Licking County Food Pantry for several years. He enjoyed rooting for OSU football, Cleveland Indians, and Cleveland Browns.

He is survived by his wife of 51 years, Alice Phillips; two grandchildren, Anna Butcher of Milwaukee, WI and Logan Crampton of St. Louisville, OH; brother-in-law, Francis "Pete" Markley of Fairview, WV; three sisters-in-law, Carolyn Jones of Farmington, WV, Mary Jane Thralls (John) of Hurricane, WV, and Donna Hill (Graham) of Atlanta, GA; two nieces, Linette and Jennifer Phillips; and several cousins.

In addition to his parents, he was preceded in death by his daughter, Lisa Renee Phillips; and brother, Ronald Phillips.

Karen Evadna (Kinney) Woods, 80, of Venice, Florida, passed away on Saturday, February 17, 2024.

Karen was born on April 19, 1943, in South Euclid, Ohio, to her parents Alfred Kinney and Evadna Mowrer Kinney. She attended Brush High School and Muskingum College, where she met her husband, James R. Woods (Jim). Karen graduated from Long Beach State College (B.S.) and Florida State University (M.S.).

Karen and Jim were married on August 31, 1963. The greatest of love stories, their excessive kissing and mantra of, "I love, love, love, love, love you," was an everyday norm for the two lovebirds.

They adopted two children-Michael (1966) and Amie (1968)-when they were both only three days old at the time. Karen adored her family, her students, and colleagues, and numerous activities-painting, walking, mahjongg, sewing, and even sky diving and roller coasters. She especially loved living in the warm climate of Florida after years of being cold in the north.

Once their children attended elementary school, Karen worked as Secretary of the United Way of Sumner County, Tennessee. Upon graduation from FSU in 1989, she began her career as a high school guidance counselor in several high schools in Florida: Venice HS; Southeast HS in Bradenton; Leto HS in Tampa; Bloomingdale HS in Brandon; Plant City HS; and Lemon Bay HS in Englewood. She retired in 2005.

Karen and Jim lived in several cities during their 60-year marriage: Columbus, Ohio; San Diego and Costa Mesa, California; Winter Haven, Florida; Nashville and Gallatin, Tennessee; Sarasota, Tallahassee, Bradenton, Valrico, and finally, Venice, Florida. She supported several charities and served on the Board of Rotary Futures program of Venice HS.

Karen is predeceased by her parents, Alfred and Evadna Kinney; her in-laws, John and Mildred Woods' her sister, Patricia Westbrook (and her husband, Russ); her brother, Fred Kinney; and her special aunt Doris Cary.

She is survived by her beloved husband, James R. Woods; son, Michael Cary Woods (Dawn); daughter, Amie Ittah (Ido); grandchildren and spouse: Paige Sottek (Nathan), Spencer Woods, and Maia Ittah; great-grandchild, Hank Sottek.

She is also survived by so many amazing in-laws (Judy, John [Norma, recently deceased], Jeff [Carolyn]), nephews (Paul and Richard Westbrook; David and Stewart Walker; Roy, Joel, and Stephen Woods; Hiatt Woods), nieces (Wendy Walker; Jennifer Rothwell; Madelyn Woods-Allen), and great-nieces and great-nephews.

Glenn Morckel, 79, of North Canton, Ohio, passed away peacefully on February 20th, 2024, surrounded by his wife Beverly, daughter Joanne and son Andrew.
Glenn was born on May 1st, 1944, to Lewis and Louise Morckel, in Salineville, Ohio. After Glenn graduated from Carrolton High School in 1962, he went on to study education at Muskingum College (New Concord, Ohio), and later attended Akron University for his master's degree.
After graduating from Muskingum with a Bachelor of Science degree in education, he started his teaching career in Canton City Schools as a junior high math teacher. Glenn finished his career in education related sales.
In 1964, Glenn met Beverly at the Augusta Strawberry Festival in Augusta, Ohio. They enjoyed two dances together the night they met, and the rest is history. Glenn and Beverly went on get married in 1966 and have two children, Joanne, and Andrew. Glenn and Beverly were married for 57 wonderful years.
In 2012, Glenn retired and above all else loved spending time with his family and friends. Glenn and Beverly traveled often to visit their daughter's family in England, son-in-law Steve and 4 grandchildren, Abigail, Hannah, Ethan, and Jessica. They would also travel to visit their son's family in Cincinnati, daughter-in-law Paige and 3 grandchildren, Olivia, Harper, and Lucas. Glenn was an avid bowler and greatly enjoyed the comradery of bowling leagues with his wife and friends. Glenn was an active member of Christ Presbyterian Church, John Knox Presbyterian Church, and The Eagles of North Canton. Glenn was an avid reader and history buff and enjoyed any western movie with John Wayne. Glenn also enjoyed taking care of the yard and gardening, with a green thumb for cherry tomatoes.
Glenn is survived by his wife Beverly, children Joanne and Andrew, his 7 grandchildren, his 8 siblings and many nieces and nephews.

Alan D. Hart, 87, of Newcomerstown, passed away on Wednesday, February 14, 2024, at his home. He was born December 21, 1936 in Coshocton to the late Robert E. and Margaret Esta (Stocker) Hart. Alan was a 1954 Newcomerstown High School graduate and then worked at Pretty Products for 33 years. He was a member of Calvary Methodist Church in Newcomerstown. He was a member of the Lonestar Lodge and was also a member of various Masonic organizations, Scottish Rite of Cambridge, Past Grand High Priest of Grand Chapter Royal Arch Masons of Ohio, Prior of Ohio Priory #18, Thirty-third Degree Mason Valley of Cambridge, Knight of York Cross of Honour, Oriental Chapter #106 Order of the Eastern Star and Elks Lodge. On May 7, 1955, Alan married Naundice (Oldt) Hart who survives. He is also survived by his son, Robert Hart (Ramona "Mona" Baker) of Heath; his daughter, Laurie (Mark) Stout of Newcomerstown; seven grandchildren; 12 great-grandchildren; four great-great-grandchildren; his in-laws, Frank D. Oldt of Newcomerstown, Mary Rose (James) Meechan of Gahanna, Terry Oldt of Canton, GA, and Sylvia Oldt of GA. He was preceded in death by his daughter, Marjorie Hart; grandson, Jason Stout; brother-in-law, Maxwell Gerald Oldt; sister-in-law, Jean Oldt. 

Dr. Katherine E. Reist, 81, Johnstown, died February 1, 2024, at home. Born December 5, 1942, in Patterson, NJ. Daughter of Gordon and Virginia (Robertson) Kennedy. Preceded in death by parents, former husband William K. Reist and brother Douglas S. Kennedy. Survived by sons Gregory K. and Michael A., and sister Carol Kennedy. Katherine was a graduate of Ridgewood High School in NJ, received her bachelor's degree from Muskingum College in OH and her masters and PHD from Ohio State University. She was a history professor at UPJ since 1988 and retired in 2023. She supported the local food pantry and donations may be made there in her memory.

Janet K. DeLucia, 80 of Lakewood, passed away on February 6, 2024 at Fairview Hospital in Cleveland. 

She was born July 1, 1943 in Youngstown, a daughter of the late John and Doris (Arp) DeLucia Burns.

She graduated from Lowellville High School, then graduated from Muskingum University in 1965 with a Bachelor’s in Education. She then earned her master’s from Kent State University and went on to teach Culinary Arts at North Olmstead, Polaris and Cuyahoga Community College.

She had a lifelong love of jazz music, the Cleveland culinary scene, travel, her friends and her family. 

She is survived by her nephew, John (Samantha) DeLucia; nieces, Dawn DeLucia and Heather (Albert Durbin) Moran and many lifelong friends from Muskingum University, the Cleveland culinary community and the Cleveland jazz community. 

In addition to her parents, she was preceded in death by her stepfather, James Burns and her brother, John “Jack” E. DeLucia.

Kenneth Leroy Pohl of Trussville, Alabama was born on February 1, 1939 in Aliquippa, Pennsylvania. He and his brother, Bill Pohl, grew up in the home of their parents, Lula and William Pohl Jr. He graduated as Valedictorian from Monaca High School. He attended and graduated from Muskingum University with a double major in physics and mathematics. After graduation he began his 40 plus years of work in the steel industry. He began in the mill portion of the Jones and Laughlin (J&L) steel mill. He eventually switched to human resources where he remained until retirement. During his tenure with J&L, the company transitioned to LTV Steel and participated in several joint ventures with other steel companies; he continued in human resources with each endeavor. The last joint venture of LTV was with Sumitomo Metal and British Steel where he held the position of Senior Vice President of Human Resources until retirement. He was predeceased by his Mother, Lula Frances Pohl and father, William James Pohl Jr. He is survived by his wife, Fran Pohl; son, Ron Pohl, Ron's wife, Carol; son, Rick Pohl, Rick's wife, Ora; daughter, Cindy Stafford, Cindy's husband, Vaughn; daughter, Deb Cunningham, and her husband, Bob; grandchildren-Jamie Godec, Jamie's significant other, Mike Hein, Adam Godec, Ron Pohl, Ron's wife Danica, Ellie Chamness, Ellie's husband, Cody, William Stafford; Sarah Lowry, Sarah's husband Gary Davenport, Scott Lowry, Jay Lowry; great grandchildren-Dak and Emmie Chamness; his brother, Bill Pohl, Bill's wife, Carol, and nephews, Bill Pohl, Bill's wife, Denise, and Philip Pohl, Philip's wife, Veronica, and many other beloved cousins and family. 

Joan Jardine Smith passed away peacefully at her home on January 15, 2024 after a long and courageous battle with leukemia. 

Joan, an avid Colorado Rapids “Super Fan” and active C-38 member, was loved by many. Her boundless kindness, generosity, and love will be sorely missed. “Aunt Joan” as she was commonly referred as; never missed a Rapids practice or game and was also a lover of nature, mountains and her church choir. There was always an extra seat (or the piano bench) at Joan’s Thanksgiving dinner and a stocking for everyone on Christmas morning. She happily welcomed anyone to celebrate with her and her family, even cooking a ‘first’ Thanksgiving dinner for many new acquaintances in Australia. 

Joan was born on July 22, 1945 to John Smith and Mary (Creed) Smith of Hamilton Township, New Jersey.  After graduating high school Joan attended Muskingum University and started as a School Teacher in Byers, Colorado. After a short time as a school teacher, Joan switched careers and began working in customer service at Mountain Bell.  Joan’s tenacity, smarts and can-do attitude were recognised and she was promoted to the position of computer programmer. Joan had a natural talent for computer programming and deeply enjoyed problem solving with her coworkers.

Throughout her life, Joan enjoyed traveling throughout the United States, Europe, Mexico and Australia. She was enamored by the lupin in Iceland, the beauty of Independence pass, the dramatic mountains in Switzerland, and the Jacaranda trees in Australia. One of her fondest memories was traveling across the US from New Jersey to San Francisco in her VW beetle, not long after finishing University. She lived a few streets away from Fisherman’s Wharf until she was down to her last penny, and then headed to Colorado for her next adventure. She never passed up on an opportunity to drive throughout the US and was always enthusiastic about a good map. She even relocated, via car, to Eagle River, Alaska where she lived with her then husband, Eugene Dobrzynski and daughter, Christina.  

Joan was preceded in death by her parents John and Mary, her sister Carol Austin-Ollom (Smith), her nephew Michael Austin, her close confidant and Pastor Carlisle Spohr, and her best friend Freckles. 

Joan is succeeded in death by her daughter Christina (Emma) Dobrzynski, brother James Smith; nieces Susan (Juan Sanchez) Austin, Kathryn (Nicholas) Walsh; nephews Jes Smith, Jake (Sarah) Austin, James (Jaclyn) Smith, Ross (Brianne) Ollom; and grand nieces Zoey and Charlotte Austin and grand nephews Jackson Smith and Ian Mullin.