Class Notes

November 22, 2016, Canton, Ohio.

September 30, 2017, Cleveland, Ohio.

Pamela Ann Winthers, class of 1970, passed away on September 5, 2019. She was a proud Muskingum alum, who went on to dedicate more than 30 years of her life to serving the children and families of Alameda County, CA, as a child welfare worker.  She is survived by her sisters, Carol and Jane, her daughter Sarah, her son Will, her daughter-in-law Lacy and her granddaughter Magdalena.

Lance Bryan Roepe, a San Jose resident who formerly lived in Campbell CA, passed away on December 23rd2020, after a recent bout with a recurring illness at 72 years of age.  Mr. Roepe was born on March 5, 1948 in New York, NY and was the only child to Elaine and Gustav Roepe.  Lance also lived in Ridgewood NJ and San Jose, CA. He was first a San Jose light rail driver then a city bus driver in San Jose until his recent retirement.  Lance was known and appreciated for his driving abilities, as well as his kindness, wit, and sense of humor.  He was a member of the board of the Amalgamated Transit Workers Union #265 and a dedicated career long member. Lance graduated Muskingum University with his bachelor’s degree in 1970, He then went on to pursue his master’s at Ohio University. Muskingum was a highlight in his life as he had many fond memories there. He continued to donate to Muskingum throughout his life and was active in their alumni group as well. Lance is survived by close friends, including a long-time friend, John Raymer of South Bend, IN. Plans of funeral arrangements are still being decided, and memorial donations can be made in Lance’s honor to Muskingum University.

Excerpt from a poem by Dylan Thomas And Death Shall Have No Dominion:

…They shall have stars at elbow and foot;

Though they go mad they shall be sane,

Though they sink through the sea they shall rise again;

Though lovers be lost love shall not;

And death shall have no dominion…

Wilmington - Andrew "Andy" James Meanor, 73, husband of Lois Helmerson of Wilmington, passed away at his home early in the morning on Monday, December 28, 2020. His passing is due to complications caused by Lewy body dementia.

Andy is survived by wife, sons Chris Meanor, Kris (Michelle) Kery, and Chris Helmerson, daughter Christine (Aaron) Wallace, and 4 grandchildren, all of Wilmington, DE. He is also survived by his older sister Joan (Sam) Holtgraver of Silver Spring, MD, and Vance (Laura) Meanor of Wilmington, NC.

Darrel Fred Herdman Obituary

Linda Klein of Matthews NC passed away Tuesday, July 27 at the Harris Hospice Unit in Charlotte, after a valiant, two-year battle with ovarian cancer. Linda was born in Ravenna OH to Paul and Merium Gibson and grew up on the family dairy farm in Edinburg OH. The oldest of four, as a child, Linda was active with her ponies, sewing, 4-H club and in high school she was a majorette for four years and on the Honor Roll. She was always very musically inclined, having studied piano from an early age and playing the clarinet, bassoon, bells, and recorder, as well. Linda attended Muskingum College in New Concord OH and graduated with her Bachelor of Arts degree from Kent State University in 1970. She played bassoon in the Akron University Symphony Orchestra and toured with them, performing in several different countries in Europe. Her teaching career started at North Royalton Elementary School in OH and she retired from Waxhaw Elementary School in 2014. She earned the National Teachers Certification while teaching in Waxhaw. Linda moved from Akron OH to Charlotte in 2001, two years after her husband, Bruce, who had moved to be closer to his parents. Linda was a devoted wife, mother, grandmother (called Oma, because she did not want to be "grandma"), sister, and aunt. As an adult she loved singing in the choir at MSLC, playing the recorder and bassoon on special occasions. Her passion for sewing continued from childhood, having made many Halloween costumes for her boys. Later in life, her sewing passion turned to quilting, which family and friends have received and cherished over the years. Survivors include her husband of 50 1/2 years, Bruce Klein; sons, Joshua (Sasha) of Cleveland OH and Benjamin (Melissa) of Lakewood OH; brother Steve (Carol) of Albemarle NC and sister, Carol (Bill) Bauman of Charleston SC. Linda leaves four grandchildren; Kazimir, Delia, Desmond and Miles; mother-in-law, Penny Klein of Douglasville GA, brother-in-law's, Chuck (Sarah) Klein of Concord NC; Dane (Becky) Klein of Rock Hill SC, and sister-in-law, Valerie (Jimmy) Gordon of Douglasville GA, many nieces, nephews and wonderful friends. Linda is preceded in death by her parents, Paul and Merium Gibson: Father-in-law, Fritz Klein, brother, Doug Gibson and best friend Martha McConnell Hatcher. The family wishes to thank Dr. Kellie Schneider, oncologist, the staff at Novant Presbyterian Medical Center and the Harris Hospice Unit for being compassionate caregivers to Linda for the past two years and special family friends for their love and support.

Kathaleen Rhoads McWilliams, age 73, passed away peacefully on Christmas Eve, her favorite night of the year, surrounded by love and to a softly sung version of Silent Night. She leaves behind an adoring family, many wonderful friends, and a grateful community who already miss her generous spirit, infectious energy, and ever-present thoughtfulness. Kathaleen lived a life dedicated to service of others and thoughtful, generous gift-giving, and her memory serves as an inspiration to carry on her beloved Rotary International’s motto of “Service Above Self”.

Kathaleen (“Kathy”) Ruth Rhoads was born on September 10, 1948 in post-war Philadelphia to Evelyn and Russell Rhoads. Over the next few years, Kathy would be joined by her brothers Russ and Ken. When she was a very young girl, she briefly moved west to Richland, Washington, but the bulk of her early years were spent in the Rhawnhurst neighborhood of Philadelphia. She attended Girls’ High for two years and then, after her family moved to the suburb of Broomall, graduated from Marple Newtown High School in 1966. One of Kathy’s favorite memories of this time was seeing the Beatles perform at the Philadelphia Convention Hall in September 1964 during the band’s second tour of the United States.

Attending college was a great adventure for Kathy, who was the first in her family to do so. She arrived on the campus of Muskingum College in the fall of 1966 and immediately found a new home. She kept herself busy with plenty of activities including a cheerleader for the football team, a sister in the Delta Gamma Theta sorority, a freshman dorm counselor, and an outstanding student with a double major in Political Science and French. Kathy was the Muskingum Homecoming Queen in 1968 (the photo accompanying this obituary is from that event). She also entered a beauty pageant (“for the money” she would later say as a defense) for “Miss Southeast Ohio” and while she came in as a runner-up, Kathy won the talent portion of the competition by playing the accordion. At college, Kathy met Darrel Fred Herdman (“Fred”) and after they graduated in 1970, the couple married and settled down in Kettering, Ohio.

The early years of Kathy’s career were devoted to teaching. She was a social studies teacher at Fairmont West High School in Kettering, where she went on to chair the Social Studies Department at the tender age of 24. One of Kathy’s greatest honors was being selected as the Ohio Teacher of the Year for social studies in 1980. Kathy’s career in education also won her recognition by the Ohio legislature on several occasions and led to her providing advice to Congress during the creation of the Commission on the Bicentennial of the U.S. Constitution.

While balancing her teaching career with the pursuit of a Master’s Degree in School Counselling at Wright State University, Kathy and Fred also enjoyed spending time with a wide number of family members in the greater Dayton area. Their weekend days were often spent poolside at the home of Fred’s parents, or at backyard barbeques attended by many friends from college and Kettering. In 1975, the couple welcomed their first child (Justin) and added to the family in 1977 with their daughter (Karah). These days during the early life of their children were joyful, with birthday parties and holidays filled with family and laughter.

In 1982, the couple moved to Coral Springs, Florida, and after an amicable divorce, Kathy pursued a new career in pharmaceutical sales. She was so successful that in 1985, her high sales number resulted in a trip to London. Kathy brought along Justin and Karah for the family’s first (but far from last) trip together. Far from relying on the scheduled itinerary, Kathy wanted to ensure that her children experienced as much of the United Kingdom as possible, so she worked in a trip to Dover, a visit with family in Bolton, and an overnight train trip to Edinburgh.

In 1988, Kathy married Dennis Ralph McWilliams and she happily welcomed two new stepsons - Jeff and Brad - into the family. The couple relocated to Bainbridge Township, where they lived for the next seventeen years, and became fixtures at Kenston High School athletic events, after-proms, and Booster Club fundraisers. During this time, Kathy spent several years as a manager at IMS Company, served her church as a deacon, and grew lifelong friendships with other members of her “Tacky Twelve” group. Kathy and Denny also travelled throughout the United States searching for a retirement location, ultimately finding the perfect spot in Hendersonville, North Carolina, where they moved in 2005.

In North Carolina, Kathy and Denny threw themselves into a retirement devoted not to themselves but to others. While Denny volunteered in the kitchen at First United Methodist Church of Hendersonville, Kathaleen renewed her love of teaching by serving as an ESL and adult literacy instructor. For three years, she devoted over 200 hours of volunteer service to the Blue Ridge Literacy Council and was awarded the “Volunteer of the Year” by the organization in 2009. She also embraced new professional roles in human resources and grant administration with Blue Ridge Community College and The Housing Assistance Corporation. They also became the parents of two little dogs – Nellie (a cockapoo) and Molly (a Shih Tzu) – who suffered only in the overabundance of affection provided to them.

After Denny sadly passed away in 2016, Kathaleen returned to the Chagrin Valley, where she was reunited with Justin’s family, and in 2020, Karah’s family as well. Kathaleen was known as “Nana Kat” to her grandchildren and she showered them with cards, gifts, and cupcakes on what seemed a weekly basis. Nana Kat also never failed to attend a soccer game, to volunteer on pickup or dropoff duty for the grandkids, or to watch the children and give their parents a night to themselves. Kathy joined the Chagrin Valley Rotary Club and did not hesitate to volunteer for any opportunity throughout the area, most notably at the Chagrin Documentary Film Festival and supporting numerous local charitable groups. In 2020-2021, Kathaleen served as President of the Rotary Club, and while her year in leadership was unexpectedly affected by the pandemic, she managed to keep the group on course and hone her Zoom skills in the process.

Kathy loved to travel. Over the years, she would visit the American West (especially Montana) many times and she also visited Alaska, Brazil, Scotland, Italy, England, and France, among other locations, with her family and dear friends. In 2019, she travelled to Ireland with Justin and Karah, where the trio had a weeklong adventure that included stumbling around in a dark, haunted castle and staying out far too late in a village pub with a falconer dressed in traditional tweed. She was a lifelong fan of reading and learning, which she passed along to her children and grandchildren. She also loved to garden and taught her daughter-in-law how to plant during a weeklong visit to Ohio in 2006, which included a memorable and hilarious drive from the garden store in a Mini Cooper jammed full with flowers and shrubs.

Kathaleen is survived by her children, Justin (Elizabeth Hijar) Herdman and Karah (John Mark) Parschauer; her stepsons Jeff (Diane) McWilliams and Brad McWilliams; her grandchildren, Lucy and Julian Herdman, John Justin, Grace, and Beatrice Parschauer, and Jalyn and Austin McWilliams; her mother, Evelyn; her brothers, Russell and Ken; and numerous nieces, nephews, cousins, and countless friends. She is preceded in death by her father, Russell, and husband, Dennis.

Linda Lee Luckey was born on February 18, 1948. She passed away on April 18, 2021 at her residence. Linda was preceded in death by her parents, William and Florence (Pulsford) Thomas; husband Hugh and their beloved Old English Sheep Dogs McDougal and Pooh. Linda is survived by her loving companion of over 20 years Michael Razor; her Aunt Doris and numerous cousins.

Linda was a graduate of Muskingum College with a Bachelor of Arts degree. In her younger years she enjoyed skeet shooting with her cousins. She was an avid photographer, wildlife observer and gardener. Linda also enjoyed travel to the North Shore and places beyond. Linda served as a Supervisor on the St. Croix County Board from 1986 through 2012. Previous to that she served as the St Joseph town clerk. In her early days she worked in the Social Security Administration.
 

J. Marc Cappell, age 73, of Dover passed away on Monday, January 10, 2022, at his home surrounded by his loving family and wife of 52 years. Born on July 2, 1948, in Dover, he was the son of the late Joe F. and Betty (Hyde) Cappell. He was also preceded in death by his favorite canine companion, Maggie. Marc graduated from Dover High School with the class of 1966. He attended Muskingum University, Kent State University, and the University of Americas in Mexico City. Marc worked in sales at many different companies in the area including Miller Beer. He enjoyed

Gardening, golfing, and was an avid Buckeye and Dover Tornado Fan. He worked on the Dover football chain gang for many years. Marc loved watching Jeopardy and was great at trivia and always had a good story to tell. His favorite pastime was driving his 1959 Thunderbird and attending car shows. Marc was a member of the First Moravian Church of Dover, the New Philadelphia VFW, and the former Dover and New Philadelphia Elks. He was also active with the Tuscarawas County Democrats and served

On the Dover City Council from 1988-2009.

He leaves behind his wife, Marla (Kail), whom he married on November 29, 1969, along with his children; Marc W. (Shannon) Cappell of McKinney, Texas, Mindi (Paul) VonKaenel of Strasburg, Marcee Joe Cappell of New York City; his brother, Richard (Mary) Cappell of Marysville, Ohio; his sister, Marcia (Mark) Swiger of Dover; along with four grandchildren, Garnet and Sophia VonKaenel, and Paige and Aly Cappell.

Carole Kay Baumbaugh, 73, born in Canton, OH, died in Cleveland Clinic Mercy Hospital on May 26, 2022. Her parents were Herle R. and Margaret L. Baumbaugh, both deceased. Carole graduated from Glenwood High School in 1966, where she enjoyed being a majorette. She attended Midwestern College in Nebraska and Muskingum College in Ohio, where she majored in Spanish and through which she enjoyed overseas Spanish-language studies in Spain. Later, she applied her considerable affinity for technology to her professional career with the Ohio Department of Disability. Carole was the very definition of sweetness and kindness, as any human or dog who knew her would lovingly confirm. She had an aura of energy that was compelling and loved music and dance. Most of all, she adored and cared intensely for her beloved dogs, Puff, Charlie, Coffee, Charlene, and others. She also deeply loved her family and contributed tender, generous care to her mother and father and to her sister, Nancy. She loved "spoiling" her niece, Julie (Jim), her nephew, Bill (Marie), and her grand-niece and nephews, Soleil, A.J., and Will.

Ann Richards passed away peacefully in her sleep on January 5, 2023 at Sterling Care in Bethesda, Maryland. Ann graduated from Carrollton High School in Carrollton, Ohio in 1966 and graduated from Muskingum College in 1970. After graduation from college, she moved to New York and began her career in finance at Merrill Lynch. In 1990, Ann moved to Washington, D.C. and began the second phase of her career, working first as the Deputy Director (and later the Director) of the Capital Markets Office of the Resolution Trust Corporation. Thereafter, she worked for USAID, first as an employee and later as a consultant. She ended her working career at Forecast on Capitol Hill. Ann loved her life in New York City, but she loved her life on Capitol Hill more, particularly her many friends, entertaining at her residences on 5th Street NE and her daily neighborhood walks. To her, Capitol Hill was home. She was actively involved in the Capitol Hill Restoration Society, the Capitol Hill Arts Workshop, and Capitol Hill Village. Ann was preceded in death by her twin sister, Susan, and by her brother, John David. She is survived by her sister, Ellen, of Columbus, Ohio and several close cousins, Mary Logue of Canton, Ohio, Joe Richards of Chagrin Falls, Ohio, Jane Huff of Columbus, Ohio, Homer Richards of North Canton, Ohio, Nora Miller of Leland, North Carolina, and their fourteen children and fifteen grandchildren. Ann passed away as a result of a cascading series of complications from Covid-19. Ann's remains will be buried with Susan's and John's in Carrollton, Ohio at a later date. 

Karen was the daughter of Mary and Warren Copeland of Lima, Ohio. Both parents preceded her in death in 2011. She now precedes her husband Mike in death along with two sisters-in-laws, two brothers-in-laws and numerous nieces and nephews through marriage. Karen was a 1966 graduate of Lima Senior High School and a 1970 graduate of Muskingum University majoring in Education. She was certified to teach kindergarten through high school students. Karen taught 5th and 6th grades in the Shawnee Ohio School System for a year. She then was hired by the Upper Arlington School System, a suburb of Columbus, where she taught for 35 years. Her first assignment was at Fishinger Rd. Elementary as a kindergarten teacher. After eight years, she taught 5th and 6th grades for two years at Fishinger Elementary and then two years at Tremont Elementary. In 1982, Karen was hired as a 7th grade math teacher at Jones Middle School where she remained until her retirement in 2007. Karen was skilled at teaching young people, maintaining order and inspiring her students. Her leadership skills and her gift for working so effectively with young people was evident at Jones when she served as its cheerleading coach. She raised money for the squad's uniforms bake sales and snack sales at football and basketball games. In addition, Karen was recommended by a math professor at Ohio State University to be on the development team for Texas Instrument's new math calculator. This took her to cities across the US for meetings with top teaching professionals. Karen could see the humor in many things resulting in a variety of classroom stories. Her humor was contagious and her students could tell she enjoyed their wit. One year she had a student whose parents owned a bar and to celebrate Cinco de Mayo, the student brought a weak Tequila mix to school and put it in Karen's small refrigerator as his contribution to the event. Unknown to Karen, she went to retrieve her lunch and discovered his contribution. She then had a little teacher student sit down. Karen had an eye for beauty in all aspects of the home design and particularly flowers and beautiful landscapes. She loved flowers and all eyes were on Karen's selection of quality and beautiful flower arrangements for her mother-in-law's funeral. She loved to cook and was constantly searching for new recipes, and she was a voracious historical and fiction reader. She enjoyed traveling with Mike especially to the Charleston, SC area as well as the Tucson, Az. area. Karen met Michel (Mike) Wilcox at a party after the inaugural Muirfield Golf Tournament in 1976. They were married in Lima March 4th, 1978. Mike graduated from Upper Arlington High School in 1966 and attended Wittenberg University and OSU. Karen will be remembered with love, and she will be greatly missed by family and friends and is with God.

Arcenaux Burma Macklin was born July 6, 1948, to the late Brunette and Wilbur Macklin, in Baltimore, Maryland.Arcenaux was a product of the New Orleans public school system and was a graduate of McDonough 35 High School. He continued his education, receiving his BA from Muskingum College in 1970 and a Master of Administration from Central Michigan University in 1993.In 1959, after two years of Catechism at Concordia Lutheran Church, New Orleans, Louisiana, he was confirmed (first communion). Arcenaux attributes his introduction to the Baptist faith to the late Rev. Evans of St. James Baptist Church, Columbus, OH. He united with the Tabernacle Baptist Church and was baptized in 1984. He applied his talents to participating in the Brotherhood Chorus, Men's Bible Class of the Church School, The Lord's Supper Pageant, and was a former member of the Angelic Choir. Arcenaux was active at Tabernacle until his health began to fail, beginning with strokes in 1999, 2003, 2004, continuing at various times up to his passing. Arcenaux believed in equal opportunity for African Americans, which was evidenced by his membership and association with Operation PUSH, NAACP, and the Columbus Urban League. He founded a peaceful desegregation advocacy group, the Red Apple, and advocated the same during the anxious per-desegregation days of 1970. He was the Entertainment editor of the Call and Post during the late 80s; and publicity manager of Center Stage Theater where he met his wife, Deborah. He also started a Boy's Club in the 1970s in the Windsor Terrace Area, called Young, Gifted, and Black. The boys enjoyed horseback riding and go-cart driving. He was employed by Western Electric, Ross Laboratories, and Ohio Bell. Arcenaux was united in marriage to Deborah Childs, on July 25, 1987, and this union was blessed with one daughter, Aziza. He was a very likable person who never met a stranger. Arcenaux was a prolific writer and loved to share his opinions in letters to several individuals. After a lengthy illness, the Lord called him into eternal rest on Sunday, October 8, 2023, at the Ohio State University Hospital with his family by his side. He leaves to cherish his memory, his wife, Deborah Macklin; daughters, Octavia and Aziza Macklin; stepchildren, Michael (April) Macklin, and Charlotte (James) Anderson; step grand, great-grandchildren, sister-in-law, Phyllis Flood; honorary daughter, Monnette Glason; nieces, nephews, other relatives, and friends.

Dennis (Denny) Richmond Barlow, 80, of Newcomerstown, passed away at home on Tuesday, October 31, 2023. He was born in 1943 in Fitchburg, MA, to the late Clement and Harriet Barlow. When he was 12, his father moved the Family to Newcomerstown, OH, to manage the Hellers (Simons) manufacturing plant. After graduating from Newcomerstown High School in 1961, he attended Worcester Polytechnic Institute in Massachusetts for two years before being drafted into the Army. After fulfilling his obligations to the United States of America, he decided he wanted to meet the love of his life. Just so happens that his future wife was a student at Muskingum University. After courting and falling head over heels for a young Deanna Durben, he decided he might as well get a dual degree in Business and Chemistry while there. Shortly after graduation, they snuck away to get married, thus making Ms. Durben, Mrs. Barlow. From that point forward, they proceeded to create a loving family. Said Family is currently crying, laughing, and reminiscing on how to describe our Family in an appropriate amount of words. Anyways, Denny and Deanna's Family consists of their lovely daughter Tammy and her husband Jeff (Zimmer), their late but impossible-to-forget son Christopher Barlow, basically son Anthony Roe and his wife Staci, kind of adopted son Seth James Barlow as a late addition, and two all-star grandchildren, Alexis and Logan Zimmer. Denny had a successful career as a plant production manager at Dover Chemical, but he thrived through his involvement in the community, endless passions, and hobbies. He was a proud and distinguished Free Mason, becoming a member of Lone Star Lodge #175 and Valley of Cambridge Scottish Rite, awarded the honorary 33 degree in 2017. He served on the school board of both Newcomerstown and Buckeye Career Center for many years. Denny was a self-proclaimed chef, cooking Masonic spaghetti dinner fundraisers, preparing breakfast for the fellowship of Isleta United Methodist Church, and roasting the most delicious Thanksgiving turkey. As a younger man, Denny played football, camped at Hickory Hollow, and enjoyed sailing and building sailboats. Later, his infatuation with the sea shifted from the water to the sky, and he became a Coshocton County Cloud Climbers model aviation club member. Over time, the New England man developed into a true country boy, enjoying hunting, fishing, raising a garden (most recently in a barrel), tapping trees and making authentic Ohio maple syrup, and helping the kids with their 4-H animals. When he wasn't pursuing one of his passions, he buggy'd around the property and neighborhood, solving the world's problems with the best friends and most wonderful neighbors he could have asked for or whoever might have cold beer on hand. He was a remarkable and beloved husband, father, and friend who will be deeply missed. 

Susan M. Cronin passed away in Naples, Florida on March 30, 2024 after a brief illness. She was surrounded by family members at her passing. Susan was a thoughtful and loving sister, spouse, mother, grandmother, and friend who will be greatly missed. She relished every opportunity to have her family around her, and she especially enjoyed being with her children and grandchildren. She is survived by her brother, Edward (Ted) Milkey; her husband, Michael D. Cronin; children, Sara Kowalczyk and her husband, Mark Kowalczyk, and Douglas Cronin and his wife, Abbey Cronin; and her four grandchildren, Brendan Kowalczyk, Julia Kowalczyk, Gus Cronin, and Will Cronin.
Susan was born in Buffalo, NY on April 6, 1948 to parents Gustave Milkey, MD and Janet Milkey. She was part of the first graduating class from Grand Island High School in Grand Island, NY before attending Muskingum College in New Concord, OH. She graduated from Syracuse University with a Master's Degree, and pursued teaching. Susan's career pivoted towards teaching writing at Syracuse University where she spent 25 years as an undergraduate writing instructor and consultant to the Maxwell School and the School of Architecture before retiring. Her love of the written word carried over to being an avid reader and belonging to book clubs in Syracuse, NY and Naples, FL.
Susan had a variety of interests including golf, reading, gardening, and playing games (especially Majong), and she was an active member of the communities she lived in. Given her keen interest in community service, Susan joined the Junior League of Syracuse in 1983 as an active and then sustainer member throughout her life. She was most proud of her work as the Parliamentarian of the League. Similarly, Susan's love of plants and flowers was evident by her long-term membership in the Four Seasons Garden Club and the countless hours she spent organizing club events and outings.
Susan also participated in the women's golf leagues at both the Onondaga Golf and Country Club in Syracuse and Eagle Creek Golf and Country Club in Florida. Susan played golf regularly with several of her friends during the summer. At Onondaga, she organized and managed the Sweeps competitions for the past several years. At both clubs, Susan enjoyed learning how to play Majong and making new friends. Whether in Syracuse or Florida, she always made time to introduce new people to the game she loved.
Despite her many activities, Susan's greatest accomplishments stemmed from her roles as a loving spouse, mother, and grandmother. Susan's greatest joy was hosting family gatherings that she would spend days preparing for, decorating the house and cooking her favorite meals and dishes to ensure that a wonderful time was had by all.

Susan M. Cronin passed away in Naples, Florida on March 30, 2024 after a brief illness. She was surrounded by family members at her passing. Susan was a thoughtful and loving sister, spouse, mother, grandmother, and friend who will be greatly missed. She relished every opportunity to have her family around her, and she especially enjoyed being with her children and grandchildren. She is survived by her brother, Edward (Ted) Milkey; her husband, Michael D. Cronin; children, Sara Kowalczyk and her husband, Mark Kowalczyk, and Douglas Cronin and his wife, Abbey Cronin; and her four grandchildren, Brendan Kowalczyk, Julia Kowalczyk, Gus Cronin, and Will Cronin.
Susan was born in Buffalo, NY on April 6, 1948 to parents Gustave Milkey, MD and Janet Milkey. She was part of the first graduating class from Grand Island High School in Grand Island, NY before attending Muskingum College in New Concord, OH. She graduated from Syracuse University with a Master's Degree, and pursued teaching. Susan's career pivoted towards teaching writing at Syracuse University where she spent 25 years as an undergraduate writing instructor and consultant to the Maxwell School and the School of Architecture before retiring. Her love of the written word carried over to being an avid reader and belonging to book clubs in Syracuse, NY and Naples, FL.
Susan had a variety of interests including golf, reading, gardening, and playing games (especially Majong), and she was an active member of the communities she lived in. Given her keen interest in community service, Susan joined the Junior League of Syracuse in 1983 as an active and then sustainer member throughout her life. She was most proud of her work as the Parliamentarian of the League. Similarly, Susan's love of plants and flowers was evident by her long-term membership in the Four Seasons Garden Club and the countless hours she spent organizing club events and outings.
Susan also participated in the women's golf leagues at both the Onondaga Golf and Country Club in Syracuse and Eagle Creek Golf and Country Club in Florida. Susan played golf regularly with several of her friends during the summer. At Onondaga, she organized and managed the Sweeps competitions for the past several years. At both clubs, Susan enjoyed learning how to play Majong and making new friends. Whether in Syracuse or Florida, she always made time to introduce new people to the game she loved.
Despite her many activities, Susan's greatest accomplishments stemmed from her roles as a loving spouse, mother, and grandmother. Susan's greatest joy was hosting family gatherings that she would spend days preparing for, decorating the house and cooking her favorite meals and dishes to ensure that a wonderful time was had by all.

James Malcolm White passed away on Wednesday, January 15, 2025 in Brecksville, Ohio at the age of 77. He is survived by his beloved wife Linda, sons Brian (Brecksville) and Brad (Montana), daughter-in-law Alonda, granddaughter Isabelle and sister Susan (Tucson). "Jdubz", or "Granpadubz", spent some of his happiest times watching fireflies with Linda, holding his granddaughter, laughing with his family, and walking the yard in Brecksville with his dog, figuring out chores for his sons to attend to.

Jim was born in Brecksville to Walter Franklin and Jane White, in the same house where he spent the last years of his life.  Graduating from Brecksville High School, Jim was active in the band and general trouble making, a skill honed on his sister, further developed at college and eagerly passed on to his sons. At Muskingum  College he met Linda, his college sweetheart, and they embarked on a 54 year adventure full of love and patience. After finishing his Masters of Planning at the University of Virginia, Jim and Linda settled in Culpepper, Virginia, where Jim was the County Administrator. beginning a long career focused on water sustainability. After decades in various spots in Virginia and Maryland, his last job brought the couple back to Brecksville, where Jim finished his career as the Director of Sustainable Infrastructure Programs at the Port Authority of Cleveland. His time at the Port was his favorite. Here he commissioned the now famous Flotsam and Jetsam, debris recovery boats designed to capture floating garbage from the Cuyahoga River. He was honored with the 2006 Ohio Lake Erie Award for his outstanding contributions to the Great Lake. Most of all, he was a tremendous motivator, well respected and loved by his colleagues.

Jim had a passion for sailing, woodworking and baseball. He was known for his irreverent sense of humor, bringing levity to any situation, and routinely drawing out Linda's infectious laugh. He was very handy and a builder of things, including a working still, decks and multiple sheds. He recently finished his life long dream project: a spectacular 14-foot wooden sail boat named Laurentia, built with an assist from his sons and his boatbuilder club, the Cleveland Amateur Boat Building Society. In his youth Jim was a Sea Scout and later went on to earn a USCO Captains License. His family remembers he was a great youth baseball coach, champion Oreo milk dunker, and a lover of plain cake donuts and Pablum. In addition, he was active in his sons' Boy Scouts programs. JDubz was also a Master Delegator, much to the chagrin of his sons, a self proclaimed nephew saver.  

It is with heavy hearts that we announce the passing of Frank R. Rodenbaugh, a beloved husband, father, grandfather, and friend, who left us unexpectedly on March 14, 2025, at the age of 77. Born on March 5, 1948, in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, son of the late Ralph and Gladys Rodenbaugh. Frank lived a life full of love, laughter, and dedication to his family.

Frank was a devoted husband to his wife Christine, whom he married on July 15, 1972. Their nearly 53 years of marriage were marked by a deep and abiding love, filled with countless cherished memories. Together, they raised
two wonderful sons, Matthew (Julie) and Andrew (Chelsea), who carry on his legacy of kindness and generosity. Frank was a proud “Pappap” to his grandchildren: Emery, Myles, Clare, Theo, and Frank, who brought immense
joy and pride to his life.

As a brother, Frank was preceded in death by his brother Ralph, who is survived by his wife Deborah.

Frank pursued a successful career in sales within the carpet industry, where his warm personality and dedication earned him respect and admiration from colleagues and clients alike.

September 26, 2018.  Asheville, NC

Marcia Lynn Rubin, age 72, of The Villages, Florida, passed away on May 24, 2022. She was born on October 19, 1949 in Alliance to Harry and Lola Orwick. After graduating from Marlington High School, Marcia received her Bachelor's degree from Muskingum University and her Master's degree from Malone University. She taught Spanish at Perry Local School, Edison Junior High. She was also the co-owner of Pleasant View Golf Club. Marcia enjoyed playing golf, cards, as well as scrapbooking. She also loved spending time with her family, especially her grandchildren. Those left to cherish her memory are her husband, Jeff Rubin; her children, Diane (Billy) Rubin-Schuld and Michael (Kristen) Rubin; grandchildren, Scarlet and Harry Schuld; brother, Donnie (Amy) Orwick; and dear friend, Sue Peoples. She was preceded in death by her parents, Harry and Lola Orwick. 

Esther Lou Jones, age 97, of Zanesville passed to the arms of her Lord and Savior, Jesus Christ on September 18, 2022. Esther was born to Merrill and Mary (Vickers) Cox in the Cox Family Farmhouse near Trinway where she spent her childhood on the farm. She graduated from Jefferson High School in Dresden, OH, attended Asbury College in Kentucky, and graduated from Muskingum University with a Bachelor of Science in Education. She began her teaching career at Chandlersville Elementary in Chandlersville, OH where she lived with her loving husband and children. She continued her career in education in the Zanesville City Schools at Wilson Elementary until her retirement in 1990 after 30 years of service. Our beloved mother and grandmother was very healthy and active well into her 90's as she worked out at the gym three days a week, enjoyed time with friends and would faithfully visit those in assisted living and health care facilities. Esther was also an active member of Central Trinity United Methodist Church of Zanesville since 1973. Esther is survived by her children: Carolyn (Rick) Searls of Taylors, SC, Phillip (Janet Jones) of Mount Vernon, OH, David Jones of Thornville, OH, Kathy (Bill) Godwin of Zanesville, OH, and Jeff (Robin) Jones of Leesburg, VA. Also surviving are a brother, Lloyd Cox of Fort Meyers, FL, eight grandchildren, fifteen great grandchildren, and several nieces and nephews. She is predeceased by her husband, Clement Jones, Jr.; grandsons: Todd Godwin, Brian Jones and Brent Jones; granddaughter Amy Jones; a daughter-in law Linda Jones; and siblings: Forest Cox, Max Cox and Gertrude Chaney. The family wishes to thank Hospice of Central Ohio for their compassionate care of Esther, as well as their encouragement and support of those family members who cared for her. 

William (Bill) Samuel Gregg, age 74, of Imperial, PA, passed to eternal rest on Thursday, December 22, 2022, at Bayberry Place Assisted Living Community in Lower Burrell. Born July 24, 1948, Bill was a 1966 graduate of Penn Hills High School and a 1970 graduate of Muskingum College. He served in the US Army from 1971-1973. Bill was employed by Duquesne Light and finished his career as a Radiation Technologist at their Beaver Valley power station at the time of his retirement. Once an avid bowler and then golfer as his health permitted, Bill also enjoyed his weekly Bible studies with friends, completing a good crossword puzzle, and watching old-time westerns and his Pittsburgh Steelers. He was a long-time member of Crossroads Church in Oakdale. Bill is preceded in death by his parents William A. and Mary (McFetridge) Gregg and his loving wife of 37 years, Bonnie (Qualey) Gregg. He is survived by his son Robert L. Gregg of Imperial; his sister Anne Jenkins (Stan) of Plum; his nieces Laura Greyshock (Shawn) of Tarentum and Sharon D'Alicandro of Plum; four great nieces/nephews; as well as many caring friends, neighbors, and church family.

George Mercer resided in Aberdeen, MD and died at Johns Hopkins Hospital, Baltimore on 22 September. He was a unique, engaging, kind, memorable man.

Born in Drexel Hill, PA to Elizabeth and Robert Mercer, George grew up and attended schools in Wilmington, DE. He graduated from P.S. du Pont High School in 1961.He enlisted in the US Army in 1965 and attended Public Information Schools at Forts Slocum and Benjamin Harrison and was later assigned to the Public Information Office at Ft. Monroe. In March 1967, he was assigned to the 1st Infantry Division in Phu Loi, Viet Nam earning a Bronze Star, Army Commendation and National Defense Service Medals.

After honorable discharge in February 1968, he returned to school and earned a BA degree from Muskingum College, New Concord, Ohio. He then worked for Planned Parenthood and Delaware Social Services and Parole Board. His civilian service with the Army began in 1982 as a Public Affairs Specialist at Perry, Point, and MD. He then held several positions at Aberdeen Proving Ground and in 1999 became Chief Public Affairs. He retired in 2011 after a distinguished career in public information with the Army. George's passion was Blue Grass and country music. From 1989 until the 2020 Covid pandemic, he co-hosted "Rural Free Delivery" on WVUD radio each Saturday afternoon. From 1975 until this year, he was a volunteer and board member of the Brandywine Friends of Old Time Music. He loved these activities and the other volunteers.

He is survived by his brothers Peter (Jane) and Tom (Patricia) and sister, Judith Mercer-Freidman (Greg), as well as niece Elizabeth and nephews Steve, James and Mark. Also surviving him is special friend Sara Crowers and her daughter Evalyn.

An incessant conversationalist and story teller, he had many friends including on Facebook and many fellow dancers at contra-dance halls along the East Coast. He also called many of those dances over the years.

George also had a large, colorful collection of Hawaiian shirts which he proudly displayed daily.

He will be dearly missed by his family and many friends. Do-si-do, George

Eric Humston, 74, formerly of Lucasville, OH, passed away on Sunday, January 21, 2024 at Adena Regional Medical Center Hospice. Eric was born June 5, 1949, in Akron OH, a son of the late Fred Paul and Catherine Joy Humston. In addition to his parents, he was preceded in death by his brother Carl Humston.

When Eric was four years old the family moved to Lucasville which became and remains his hometown. He was a proud graduate of the Valley High School Class of 1967 serving as Class President and co-valedictorian. He received a Bachelor's of Arts Degree from Muskingum College in 1971. Eric excelled in both academics and athletics, receiving honors in both areas and was drafted by the San Diego Chargers of the NFL. He served in the U.S. Army Reserve 1001st Field Service Company, from 1971-1977. He completed a Master's Degree in school counseling from Ohio University in 1977, and an Educational Specialist Degree in school administration from Ohio University in 2000.

Eric worked as a teacher, coach, counselor, and administrator in a number of school districts in Southeast and Southern Ohio including his alma mater where he is a member of the Valley Board of Education Hall of Fame. He concluded his 43 years in public education as Director of the State Support Team Region 15 providing assistance to school districts in the areas of early childhood, special education, and school accountability and improvement.

He is survived by his sisters Cathie Martin of Lucasville, Ellen Devins of Minford; his children Kariah Humston and Trevin Humston both of Clarktown; several nieces and nephews; and special friends Layla McCleese and Dacota Wetmore of West Portsmouth.

Jack Crowther, 74, passed away in Gainesville, GA on March 8, 2024, after a brief illness. 

Jack received a Bachelor of Science Degree from Muskingum with majors in math and physics. During his Muskie years he was a member of the men's basketball team and the Ulster Club.

Following graduation, Jack returned to his hometown of Elyria, Ohio and lived there until 2015, when he moved to Georgia. He was a businessman and enjoyed playing and watching sports, especially basketball and baseball. He was immensely proud of his children and grandchildren.

Jack is survived by sons Nicholas (Ben Esthus) and Zachary (Megan Hunter); daughter Casey (Timothy) Clauss; grandsons Calvin, Owen, Miles and Colson; wife 1971- 2015 Laurine (Namy) Muskingum Class of 1971.
 

Dennis Deal, 75, formerly of Kent, passed away in New York City on May 18, 2024. He was born on November 8, 1949, in Kansas City to Katherine and Paul Deal. After living in several cities, the family moved to Kent in the early 1960’s. He graduated from Roosevelt High School, where he was an outstanding student; senior class president, participated in many theatre productions and the marching band, and won the American Legion Outstanding Student award. In 2001, he was inducted into the Kent School Hall of Fame. Dennis wrote and recorded an ode to the city entitled “Kent Is…” for a civic celebration.

He attended Muskingum University and after graduating from Kent State University with an MFA in Music and Theater in 1972, he moved to New York City where he lived the rest of his life. He was a multi-talented artist—singer, dancer, arranger, writer, and director in many media—theatre, concerts, television and movies. For many years he was the bass singer in the a cappella group The Accidentals. He also wrote and directed the musical Nite Club Confidential which appeared Off Broadway, on London’s West End, and in L.A. and Boston. Dennis donated many hours of his time by mentoring other singers, writing a musical for izzit.org, the Free to Choose Network, and too many others to mention.

Dennis is fondly remembered by all those with whom he came in contact, in Ohio, New York, and everywhere, for his talent, quick wit, and his joyous spirit. He will be sorely missed.

Dennis is predeceased by his parents and his brother Douglas. He is survived by a niece, Dianna Deal, and several cousins. The family wishes to thank his devoted friend and caretaker Laura Kenyon, and the staff at Amsterdam House who adored his singing and sense of humor. 

John Duane Corbett (Duane) died peacefully at home, surrounded by loved ones on December 28, 2024. Duane was born May 23, 1949, in Wheeling, West Virginia, to Irvin and Dorothy (Hall) Corbett. Duane grew up in the small town of Harrisville, Ohio, and enjoyed many childhood jobs. He worked for a small flower company down the road from his home, which began a lifelong love of flowers, worked construction for his uncle's construction business, and painted at his father's Carson Petroleum filling stations. As a child, Duane developed a lifelong love of music from his mother.

He was a 1967 graduate of Adena High School (Adena, Ohio) and a 1971 graduate of Muskingum College (New Concord, Ohio), with a Bachelor of Music Education. At Muskingum, he was a member of the Ulster Club.
After college, Duane became the head band director at Teays Valley High School (Ashville, Ohio) from 1974-1985. During this time, he took bands to several competitions, some of which were played in Ohio Stadium (Columbus, Ohio). His band also had the privilege of playing at an Ohio State men's basketball game, with the band sitting right behind one of the baskets in St. John Arena (Columbus, Ohio). Duane remembered this as a really great experience. On two occasions, his band was invited to Riverfront Stadium (Cincinnati, Ohio) and played for a Cincinnati Reds baseball game and a Cincinnati Bengals football game. They also performed at Walt Disney World in Orlando, Florida. Additionally, during this season of Duane's life, he often played his trumpet and accompanied the musical worship at Circleville Presbyterian Church (Circleville, Ohio).

After teaching, Duane became a Foreign Expert Trainer for ZTE Corporation in Shenzhen, China, where he worked from 2007-2012. He was an academy lecturer and responsible for the corporation's global corporate employee training program.

Duane's hobbies included being a lifelong Ohio State fan, fishing, being outdoors, and spending time with his family.

He is preceded in death by his parents Irvin and Dorothy Corbett, brother Rev. Dr. Lawrence Corbett, and niece Courtney Corbett Zink. He is survived by his wife Zhu Xiaoling, children Kara Landefeld (J. Michael), Jonathan Corbett (Julie), and Zhu Yi, sister Marcie Smith (Richard), sister-in-law Meredyth Corbett, grandchildren Jacob and Elizabeth Landefeld, and Grace, Hope, and Ruth Corbett, nieces Erin Randolph (Brian) and Julie Atkins, nephews Matthew Corbett and Greg Smith (Melissa), as well as several great nieces and nephews.

Betty Colin Dasch, age 99, of Medina and formerly of New Concord, passed away peacefully on April 11, 2025, at Brookdale Camelot Senior Living in Medina, Ohio.

Born in Steubenville, Ohio, Betty was one of six children of Joseph and Katherine (Boxdorfer) Colin. She was a proud member of the Steubenville High School Class of 1943 and went on to earn her Bachelor of Arts Summa cum laude degree from Muskingum College in New Concord in 1971.

A devoted member of Christ’s Evangelical Lutheran Church in Cambridge, Ohio, Betty was active in numerous organizations throughout her life, including the Federated Club, the New Concord Jack and Jill Mothers’ Club, Feed My People, and the Women of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America (WELCA). She attended ten national WELCA conventions. She traveled and camped extensively across North America from Alaska to Costa Rica with her husband.

Betty wore many hats in life — devoted stay-at-home mom, Sunday school teacher, Cub Scout den mother, adult college student, Spanish language teacher, volunteer, and faculty wife. Alongside her husband, she became an amateur insect collector and helped identify map locations, proof read, and type several of his published books. Visiting, caregiving, and quilt making for Lutheran World Relief occupied much of her free time in later years.

For the past six years Betty has lived at Brookdale Camelot, in Medina, where she was known for welcoming new residents. She was an associate member at Zion Lutheran Church in Valley City, but remained a generous supporter of Christ’s Lutheran Church in Cambridge.

Betty married her beloved husband, Clement E. Dasch, on December 30, 1947. He preceded her in death on November 29, 2007. She was also preceded in death by son James R. Dasch March 28, 2017, and siblings Ray (Mary) Colin, Dorothy (George) Burnett, Claire (Maurice) White, Robert (Marcia) Colin, and Alice (Gerald) Minto.

She is survived by her sons: Gregory (Marina) Dasch, Cameron (Jean) Dasch, and Richard (Barbara) Dasch; daughter-in-law, Amy Dasch; nine grandchildren: Jennifer (Ryan) Brown, Jeffrey (Christina) Dasch, Andrew (Jess) Dasch, Katy (Mark) Dasch, Sam Dasch, Trevor (Meredith) Dasch, Matthew Dasch, Peter (Marisa) Dasch, TJ (Madeline) Dasch; six great-grandchildren: Oliver, Jason, Jesse, and Sarah Brown, Brandon and Tristan Dasch; as well as many nieces, nephews, and dear friends.

Charles “Charley” Stevens, 68, of Hillsboro, Ohio, went to be with the angels Saturday, August 24, 2019 after a courageous battle with cancer.

He was born October 1, 1950 in Cambridge, Ohio, the son of John Thomas and Marjorie (Bowers) Stevens.

Charley was a 1968 graduate of Cambridge High School and a 1972 graduate of Muskingum College.  He was a member of the Quaker City Lodge # 500 and Scottish Rite of Cambridge.  He was also a member of the Greenfield Rotary Club where he was a Paul Harris Fellow recipient, past president of the Highland County Chamber of Commerce and original member of the first class of Leadership Highland.

Charley was the owner of Stevens Hardware in Greenfield, Ohio for 29 years.  Prior to hardware business he was the former co-owner of Stevens Markets in Cambridge, Quaker City, Senecaville, and Dresden.

He is survived by his wife of 38 years, Lynn (Shisler) Stevens; mother, Marjorie Siders of Hillsboro; mother-in-law, JoAnn Shisler of of Canton; two sisters-in-law, Terri Ehret of Canton, Cathy Folkert Stevens of Cambridge; brother-in-law, John (Cindy) Shisler of Canton; two nephews, Paul Ehret and Nathan Shisler both of Canton; niece Victoria Shisler of Florence, KY.

He was preceded in death by his father, John Thomas Stevens; brother, Thomas M. Stevens; Step father George Siders; father-in-law, Howard Shisler; and sister-in-law, Paula Shisler.

Craig J. Graham, 72 of Avon, OH passed away Wednesday, October 21, 2020. He was born October 6, 1948 in Evanston, IL to parents Frank and Gwendolyn (nee Harvey) Graham.

Craig was a Rocky River graduate and received his bachelor's degree from Muskingum University where he was a member of the MACE fraternity and his master's degree from Baldwin Wallace University. He is a U.S. Army veteran that was stationed in Germany. Craig enjoyed gardening and yardwork, DIY home improvements, spending time at the beach and watching movies. He was kind and compassionate, always helping his kids and neighbors with their projects. His family was his pride and joy; always making time to coach or referee and attend their games. He loved watching his grandchildren in all of their sports.

He is survived by his loving children Scott Graham (Amy), Jamie Weaver (Jeffery) and Debbie (nee Mason) Templin (Jim); cherished grandchildren Zachary, Addison, Logan, Avery, Jamisa (Casey), Jimmy (Karlie) and Kiersten; and 4 great-grandchildren; dear brothers Bruce Graham (Fran) and Kevin Graham.

He is preceded in death by his beloved wife, Sandra and his parents.

Ms. Kay Ann Nelson passed away on April 14, 2022.

Willard Rae Mills, Jr., 69, of Wintersville, OH, passed away January 4, 2019 at Trinity Medical Center West, Steubenville.

He was born November 21, 1949 in Steubenville, OH, a son of the late Willard R. Mills, Sr. and Virginia (Lassiter) Mills.

Willard was a member of the Covenant Presbyterian Church.

He was an avid follower of Steubenville Big Red and the Pittsburgh Steelers.

Willard was a devoted family man. He was a teacher, coach, and funeral director.

Willard is survived by his loving wife, Kathy Mills of Wintersville, OH; sons, Bryan (Katie) Mills of Steubenville, OH; daughters, Lisa (Steve) Jolly of Mason, OH, Tiffany Pierro of Steubenville, OH, Jennifer (Todd) Blackburn of Wintersville, OH, and Kristen Mills of Fairborn, OH; sister, Peggy Stout of Pittsburgh, PA; 9 grandchildren, Jessica and Matthew Jolly, Michael and Mia Pierro, Cooper and Nolan Blackburn, Dugan, Carmen, and Mae Mills.

Thomas "Tom" Charles Barry, age 73, of Grand Haven, formerly of Ohio, passed away on Tuesday, July 9, 2024, at Dogwood Shores Assisted Living. He was born on July 27, 1950, in Brownsville, PA, to the late Charles and Christine (Dobrunick) Barry. Tom graduated from Muskingum University with a degree in Psychology. He spent 40 years in various positions at harness racing tracks including Ohio, Maryland, and Washington DC. He also managed professional and tough man competition boxers. Tom enjoyed playing card games, scrabble, listening to music, and the Cleveland Browns. Tom is survived by his sisters, Christine (Kenneth) Lee and Winona Lee Goldstein; nephews, Kenneth (Erin) Lee and C.D. Goldstein; niece, Beth Sheinbaum; great-nephews, Parker (Joy) Lee and Matthew (Jane) Coogan; great-niece, Payton Lee; and many cousins and friends. Tom was preceded in death by his parents and brother-in-law, Sam Goldstein

It is with heavy hearts that we announce the passing of Bob Dougherty, a beloved father, husband, grandfather, and dedicated co-owner of Zane Casket Company.

Robert Charles Dougherty, 74, of Norwich, born February 16, 1950 in Zanesville, OH, affectionately known as “Bob” to all who knew him, passed unexpectedly on December 1, 2024. Bob was a graduate of Zanesville High School and went on to earn his education degree at Muskingum College, a reflection of his firm belief in the importance of a good education. After college he chose to work for the family business, Zane Casket Co., with his father C.A “Doc” Dougherty and beloved brother Bill. Over the years, Bob and his siblings worked hard to build and grow the company, and Bob eventually became the president. His leadership and dedication to the business was admirable, and he worked every day to ensure its success.

Outside of work, Bob enjoyed the simple pleasures in life like a good home cooked meal and a workout in the gym. He had a deep appreciation for outdoor work on the farm, particularly mowing grass and splitting wood. Bob found joy in these tasks, and they were a peaceful respite from his busy life. When the farm work was done, he was ready to share a drink in the “camaraderie of friendship” with his friends whom he often referred to as “brothers in heart throughout life”. Bob leaves so many great memories for family and friends to cherish as he was known for his love of a good song and lively conversations. Everyone was welcomed into his home in Norwich to gather and enjoy time together. His intelligence and wit were easily recognized by all who met him, and his generosity, humor, and loyalty made him a true friend to many, and his presence will be deeply missed by all who knew him.

Bob was proceeded in death by his treasured wife, Mary M. Dougherty, his parents C.A. and Lora Dougherty, sister Betty Dougherty, a great grandson Bennett Wayne Mitchell-Gower, and beloved dog Mocha Jo.

He is survived by his brother William “Bill” Dougherty of Zanesville; daughters: MaryAnn Hughes of New Concord; Deanna (Dan) Eshler of Louisville, OH, grandchildren: Mileena (Eric) Malen and Adam Mitchell, Sarah and Ryan Hughes, Trevor and Annaliese Eshler; 2 great grandchildren Finn and Lily Malen; nephews: Robert (Michelle) Dougherty of Nashport, OH and Danny (Alaina) Dougherty of Zanesville, niece Michelle (Jeff) Benoist of Flower Mound, Texas and cherished dog Zinc.

June 6, 2018, Bozeman, Montana.

June 6, 2018, Bozeman, Montana.

Amy Carol Smith died peacefully at her home in North Wales, Pennsylvania, on July 26, 2021, after a two-year battle with cancer, a diagnosis she handled with pragmatism and grace. Amy was born on July 13, 1951, the daughter of Wendell and Ruby Smith, and grew up in Minerva, Ohio. She graduated from Minerva High School in 1969 and Muskingum College in 1973. After college she joined the United Methodist US-2 mission program for young adults, serving two years in Hazelton, Pennsylvania. She then attended United Theological Seminary in Dayton, Ohio, and was ordained in 1976, a proud member of the first wave of women clergy in the United Methodist Church. She served many churches in the Eastern Pennsylvania Conference during her career, most recently Lehman Memorial United Methodist Church in Hatboro, and the First United Methodist Church of Phoenixville. She remained active in the conference even after her retirement in 2012. Amy was known for her long and steadfast friendships, her love of ice cream and baseball, and her inherent frugality. She will be deeply missed by her husband of 24 years, Timothy D. Caum, his three children and four grandchildren, who Amy loved as her own; her three siblings, Melissa (Dan) Clayton, Andrew (Ellen) Smith, and Sarah (Bill) Lange; her niece and three nephews. Amy's life was enriched by her church community, neighbors, and friends she cherished. The family wishes to thank them for their love and support during her illness.

William (Bill) T. Culbertson passed peacefully in his home on March 15. Born July 30, 1951, in Toledo, Ohio, to parents William E. and Phyllis A. (Thurston) who predeceased him. Bill graduated from Bowling Green High School in 1969 and attended Muskingum University, graduating with a business degree in 1973. After college, he began a career in banking that would span more than 45 years, spending many years with Huntington Bank and fully retiring from Signature Bank in 2020. Active in the greater Bowling Green community, Bill served as past President of the Bowling Green Chamber of Commerce and as Trustee of Wood County Hospital. He was also a proud member of the Bowling Green City Council for 8 years and a longtime member of the Bowling Green Board of Utilities. Bill enjoyed spending his spare time outdoors biking, golfing and tending to his yard. He also enjoyed reading, bourbon, and live music most recently he visited his favorite haunt, The Slippery Noodle Inn. He loved sports from coaching little league baseball, supporting his children's athletic adventures, loyally supporting any Detroit team along with the Buckeyes and recently cheering on his grandkids. Left to cherish his memory are Tam Rolf, his committed partner, his children, the pride of his life: David (Danielle) of Columbus, Ohio, Michael (Melinda) of Canton, Ohio and Stephen (Shannon) of South Lyon, Michigan, and their mother. He was thrilled to be GP to seven incredible grandchildren: Gabrielle, Isabelle, Miles, Elliott, Stella, Lucas, and Andrew. Always a loving brother, he is survived by his sister Hollis (Ed) Pearson of Westampton, New Jersey and her family. He was blessed to have countless friends who loved him, including Tam's extended family, and colleagues who admired and respected him.

Edna Sharp 93 of Richmond, Ohio passed away March 3, 2023 at Gables Care Center. She was born April 7, 1929 in Cumberland, Maryland a daughter of the late James and Elizabeth (Kyle) Hawkins. In addition to her parents she was preceded in death by her husband, Robert B. Sharp; grandsons, Mark Adam Moore and infant grandson, Steven Robert Moore; brothers, Morris and Raymond Hawkins; sister-in-law, Ila Faye Hawkins. 

Edna was a graduate of Muskingum College. Her first job in education was teaching at Unionvale then Irondale and spent most of the years as a teacher at Edison Local mainly with kindergarten and first grade. She was a former member of Annapolis Presbyterian and was a member of Richmond Presbyterian Church where she played the piano for many years. She loved her grandchildren and always enjoyed watching them in sports and other activities. For many years after retirement Edna spent winters in Florida with her husband. 

She is survived by her daughters, Leslie (Greg) Smith and Mary Ann (Steve) Moore; grandsons, Rob (Val) Moore and Stevie (Kacey) Moore; great-grandchildren, Dylan, Marcus, Lydia, and Chloe; brothers, Carl (Stella) Hawkins, Johnny (Sally) Hawkins, Neil (Carolyn) Hawkins, Nancy (Rich) Taylor, sister-in-law, Ruth Hawkins.